search

journalovi / journalovi.github.io

The JoVI website in Quarto
https://www.journalovi.org/
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
12 stars 2 forks source link

How to comment on a published article? #29

Open floe opened 1 year ago

floe commented 1 year ago

AFAICT this is not something that OJS can support out of the box. Ideas welcome...

mjskay commented 1 year ago

Ahhh interesting. For the experimental track, I think we can have github issues, and maybe even think about one of those systems that allow comments on a webpage to be backed by github issues...

For the normal track, we could also try one of those things (like https://hypothes.is ?). Or maybe people should submit such things as commentaries?

mjskay commented 1 year ago

But the question with commentaries might be how to review those...

floe commented 1 year ago

And the barrier is probably much higher to submit an explicit commentary article, than just writing a few words. I had forgotten about hypothes.is, I think this could be a good idea to integrate.

floe commented 1 year ago

There's even an OJS plugin: https://github.com/asmecher/hypothesis (or we integrate the script directly, as per https://web.hypothes.is/help/embedding-hypothesis-in-websites-and-platforms/ ).

mjskay commented 1 year ago

yeah, though then we also have to make sure we're moderating comments if we use something like hypothesis, right? maybe we should test this out or something... could test it out on the mission statement PDF if we wanted?

floe commented 1 year ago

Update: the library folks have enabled the Hypothes.is plugin on our OJS install, so you should be able to comment on any PDFs now. Should we also announce this somewhere? It's not very obvious IMHO (tiny button on the top right).

mjskay commented 1 year ago

Let's not announce it yet, since it might be good to test it out and decide if it's the style of commenting we want?