search

jphung11 / COGS121

0 stars 0 forks source link

Milestone 3 feedback #2

Open kandarpksk opened 7 years ago

kandarpksk commented 7 years ago

Write comments below, not in a separate thread.

michichama commented 7 years ago

Team C1: Did not show. Could not do feedbacks.

streddy commented 7 years ago

Team C5: JSOT

Alex: I like that the storyboard illustrates what you would like to accomplish very clearly. I think the idea of using food images in order to spark interest in what to eat is kind of a neat idea.

I wish that the maps aspect for the app was a bit more prevalent. Your storyboard shows that the user can get directions from the app for locations that hold a specific type of food. However, the maps aspect isn't really displayed in any of the panels.

Todd: I like how you use pictures of food to help users determine if they are down to eat something. It does indeed make the food more enticing and makes decisions on the user easier. I think its a great idea, and it solves the user needs you seem to have defined. I also liked how clear your story board is (props to person who drew) and it really helped me understand what need your app is addressing and how you plan to solve that need

I wish there was a more social aspect to this, overall I can see this being useful when I'm alone, but it may be difficult in large groups. Crowding around a single phone to decide on what to eat generally isn't very ideal in my opinion.

Sanjeev: I like the way you differentiated your application from Yelp. It sounds like a fresh and unique idea that solves the identified problem in a novel way. Your storyboard was extremely well done and clearly identified a problem, problem-solving, and reaching a solution. I like the different features that you plan on implementing--especially the "favorites" section and food reviews. I also like how detailed you were in distributing the work.

I wish that maps were a more central focus of the application. Right now, it feels as though the food recommendation takes a center stage and that the maps aspect is added as an afterthought. Maybe an easy way to solve this problem would be to include a map on the main page of the application and have the pictures of food pop up one-by-one over the location of their corresponding restaurant. The user could then swipe left or right on each image as it popped up.

Albert: sick for the day :(