search

jpswalsh / academicons

An icon font for academics
https://jpswalsh.github.io/academicons
790 stars 102 forks source link

Violation of Orcid license conditions #131

Open GrahamCampbell opened 4 years ago

GrahamCampbell commented 4 years ago

Conversion of the orcid logo to black and white is not permitted unless it is used in a black and white print, however it appears on a colour rendered page: https://jpswalsh.github.io/academicons/.

GrahamCampbell commented 4 years ago

https://orcid.org/trademark-and-id-display-guidelines

sssoz commented 4 years ago

@GrahamCampbell ORCiD’s green (#a6ce39) is not often WCAG-compliant on most background colours, including #ffffff white, (so it’s not accessible) and also doesn’t look good on many other background colours.

GrahamCampbell commented 4 years ago

@sssoz Unfortunately that doesn't constitute a valid exception to their license terms. You should raise the issue of accessibility directly with them. The only solution is to not show their logo at all if you are worried about being sued for accessibility breaches. Changing their logo colour could get you sued by them.

sssoz commented 4 years ago

@GrahamCampbell I mean, the reason people think about accessibility is not because they are worried about being sued, but because they care about user experience.

GrahamCampbell commented 4 years ago

Well, yes, but in order to comply with the license, that means you cannot show the logos to anyone.

L-TChen commented 3 years ago

FontAwesome provides this icon as well, so probably removing this icon from academicons may resolve this issue for now. However, it appears to me that the license is not really well-thought-out...

lucjaulmes commented 3 years ago

The academicon page currently says « All product names, logos, and brands are are the property of their respective owners. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement. » to which could be added something along the lines of « Ensure that you have the legal right to do use trademarked logos, and see the trademark owner for rules about their appropriate use. » (which is similar to what WikiMedia and FontAwesome use).

Then it’s each user’s responsibility to make the icon orcid green #a6ce39 or use it on black-and-white pages, and all of their other rules (only use the icon next to an id, etc. etc.). That should probably also cover #124.