search

jridgewell / Unlock

Unlock multiple Core Storage encrypted volumes at boot.
MIT License
197 stars 34 forks source link

about "I'm user A. What if user B logs in? Will my home drive be mounted?" #12

Open tjluoma opened 10 years ago

tjluoma commented 10 years ago

Let me start by saying that I'm nowhere near knowledgeable about how this works, so my apologies if this is a dumb idea, but regarding this:

The program is not aware of who is logging in and I don't know of a way to make it aware other than making it a User LaunchDaemon, which won't work. A pull request implementing this would be greatly appreciated.

What about a LoginHook? If the user logging in != the user whose $HOME is encrypted, then unmount the encrypted $HOME. Would that gain you anything?

(ISTM that the FileVault 2 must know which user has requested the unlock/login, because it's going to auto-login to that user's account, right? But I have no idea if that information is available programmatically.)

mattpr commented 6 years ago

Let's say you have partition "Users" that you want to have mounted under path /Users.

If filevault is encrypting/decrypting the whole partition... then it doesn't make sense to encrypt/decrypt files for only a single user. The volume gets decrypted so it can be mounted at /Users so that users can login. Protection to keep UserA from looking at UserB's files are provided by the operating system and the same as when FileVault/encryption isn't in use.