search

js-org / js.org

Dedicated to JavaScript and its awesome community since 2015
https://JS.ORG
5.21k stars 3.44k forks source link

webwork.js.org #9187

Closed slatev1 closed 1 month ago

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

I understand that you though slatev1.js.org was name grabbing, to actually get a name suitable for my cli website making tool, I have decided to make it webwork.js.org.

Thanks in advance.

MattIPv4 commented 1 month ago

I still believe this to be name-grabbing, I think you should focus on actually building your CLI tool first, getting it into a good state, and then worry about a js.org subdomain for it later.

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

@MattIPv4

Then what is a name that you approve of that is not name-grabbing

MattIPv4 commented 1 month ago

The name itself is not the issue, it is the fact that you've been spamming us with subdomain requests for a site with very little content of substance... as I said above, focus on actually building your CLI tool first, and then worry about a subdomain from js.org after.

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

Alright thanks

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

@MattIPv4

The thing is that it says on your website (js.org), “ Your page just has to provide some reasonable content with a clear connection to JavaScript!”, it doesn’t say anything about me having an npm package and stuff like that, my website has clear connection to JavaScript as I have files for a JavaScript CLI tool which I will publish once I will get a subdomain.

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

In my option I believe that I should be granted access to a subdomain as I meet the requirements. Anyways, me actually doing it is a suggestion from you but I have the requirements to get a subdomain. It doesn’t say anything about actually doing it as you suggested.

slatev1 commented 1 month ago

I don’t understand why you don’t want to give me a subdomain, I have followed the steps on the website very clearly, I just don’t see why not.

indus commented 1 month ago

You joined Github 2 days ago, have a single repository with a single JavaScript file with only 70 lines of code (a good part of it static text) and expect to get a subdomain for it? Really? This is a new low that I can't accept - not after the request has already been rejected 4 times and it looks like you would rather put energy into creating pull requests than into the content of the page.