Low reCAPTCHA score

[erichschroeter]

Trying to log in as a guest, with Github, or with Google I receive a popup saying "Low reCAPTCHA score". I also tried signing up with my email address and got the same result.

[jackwootton]

@erichschroeter Thanks for taking the time to create this issue. Can you provide you browser details?

[erichschroeter]

Version 1.11.104 Chromium: 84.0.4147.105 (Official Build) (64-bit) Not sure if it matters, but it's the Brave browser.

[JeffMTI]

@erichschroeter - coincidentally -- I have the same problem -- also with Brave. Was able to login on Opera and Chrome itself

[jackwootton]

From the Brave Community Google ReCaptcha seems to give Brave users a bad score

The problem is that ReCaptcha relies on user tracking and fingerprinting, both things that Brave does its best to reduce or eliminate for privacy reasons.

Note that this doesn’t have anything to do with the user agent string because Brave currently uses the same user agent string as Chrome.

You'll have to set shields to DOWN to login, however after logging in, you can set shields to UP.

[csuwildcat]

I can't get past this either, just keeps reporting this error no matter how I try to access the site.

[jackwootton]

@csuwildcat What browser are you using? Do you have any ad blockers installed? There are no adverts on www.jsonschema.net but the may interfere with the recapthca algorithm?

[testQx]

I can't get the schame Http failure response for https://prod.json.systems/v1/graphs:inferGraph: 0 Unknown Error

[jackwootton]

@testQx What browser are you using? Do you have any ad blockers installed? There are no adverts on www.jsonschema.net but the may interfere with the recapthca algorithm.

[csuwildcat]

@jsonsystems I am using Microsoft Edge (Chromium), which has a built-in feature for added tracker/privacy protections. Given this is now a major browser, and the feature that is likely triggering this failure is native to it, my guess is you're going to see a lot of this. (probably the same story for folks using Brave)

[jackwootton]

@csuwildcat Do you mind posting your score? Using a developer console look for the HTTP POST request to https://jsonschema.net/api/captcha. It will look something like:

action: "login"
challenge_ts: "2020-08-10T14:38:51Z"
error-codes: null
hostname: "jsonschema.net"
score: 0.9
success: true

[csuwildcat]

@jsonsystems oddly, I just tried again as a guest and got in, and when I submitted a change to the editor, it also worked. Nothing on my side changed, that I am aware of.

[jackwootton]

@csuwildcat Sounds like I need to look into this. When you experienced the problem were you attempting to sign up, login, or infer a schema?

[carlos-oliver]

Hello, I have this problem, I can't access. I need help, please. @jsonsystems

[jackwootton]

@carlos-oliver Sorry you're hitting this problem too. What browser and OS are you using? Do you have any ad blockers installed?

[carlos-oliver]

@ carlos-oliver Desculpe, você também encontrou este problema. Qual navegador e sistema operacional você está usando? Você tem algum bloqueador de anúncios instalado?

Hello, @jsonsystems my operating system is windows 10 professional. My browser is Google Chrome version 78.0.3904.97. I have no blockers.

This problem started to occur after I made several requests in a row. I was giving another message and I had to make several requests.

[Detnator-Neo]

Hi there. I've just posted in #95 and #97 with my setup and noting that I'm getting both errors reported above in this #94 (low recaptcha score and http failure response). I'm using Safari and Safari Tech Prev on macOS.

These browsers natively have shields up - and most users aren't going to want to drop them, right? - and so I'd posit that as @csuwildcat said above, you're going to get a lot of these issues from Mac users as well for the same reasons he described.

Also having other issues with latest Chrome (85.0.4183.102) on same Mac - just spins its wheels and never gives result. Not sure if it's related.

Hope this helps. Any way you can change things in the site to avoid these?

[jackwootton]

I've changed the reCAPTCHA threshold, can you give it a go at www.jsonschema.net and let me know if this works for you?

Thanks.

[miqui]

@jsonsystems - hi, this is still a problem. Chrome: Version 84.0.4147.89 (Official Build) (64-bit)

[jackwootton]

@miqui Can you provide the HTTP response from the recaptcha request https://jsonschema.net/api/captcha?

[nickeyvee]

@jsonsystems I too am having this same issue on the brave browser. When I try to log in to Chome with the same credentials it works fine.

• Request URL: https://jsonschema.net/api/captcha
• Request Method: POST
• user-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/86.0.4240.99 Safari/537.36

Response payload:

{
   "success":true,
   "score":0.1,
   "action":"login",
   "challenge_ts":"2020-10-24T15:30:14Z",
   "hostname":"jsonschema.net",
   "error-codes":null
}

[jackwootton]

@nickeyvee Do you have Shields up?

[sergei-iurchenko]

I have the same issue. Google Chrome Google Chrome is up to date Version 87.0.4280.141 (Official Build) (x86_64) mac os 10.15.7

[jackwootton]

this should be resolved on the new version.