juamiji1 / ethnographic-atlas

0 stars 0 forks source link

Fixing EA ethnicities by using the EA CLUSTER number #7

Open juamiji1 opened 2 months ago

juamiji1 commented 2 months ago

Some EA ethnicities had NA in all motifs in the raw dataset (raw/folklore/data/Replication_Data_Folklore/Original_Files/Motifs_EA_groups.dta). I fixed them using the following algorithm:

  1. For each specific ethnicity I got their respective EA cluster number code (v114) .
  2. With the code, I looked other ethnicities in the same ethnic cluster.
  3. If there was just one other ethnicity in the cluster, I assigned the motif values of that one to the NA one.
  4. If there were more than one, then I assigned the closest one that was not in the 'others' category in the book of Murdock (1967) . Example: pic2
  5. In the case of group 369, all the other groups were in the 'others' category, so I made the imputation based on language.
  6. In the case of group 120, I used the 1st other ethnicity that appeared in the book. Since it is an island in the middle of the Pacific colonized by explorers the closest ethnicity did not make sense to me.

Final result:

Atlas (v107) EA Cluster (v114) Berezkin code (oid) Berezkin group name Imputed ethnicity Reason
BRAZILIAN 117 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Discussed with Nathan
BAGIRMI 70 674 Sara SARA Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
CANTONESE 164 10024 Fujian Chinese MINCHINES Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
DJUKA 369 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Language based on Portuguese according to Murdock (1967) - book
SARAMACCA 369 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Language based on Portuguese according to Murdock (1967) - book
FUR 98 NA NA NA No other info available
GUATO 398 NA NA NA No other info available
HUTSUL 126 195 Czech CZECHS closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
IDOMA 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi AFO closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
IGALA 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi AFO closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
KORO 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi AFO closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
KURAMA 63 461 Manden,Bamana,Malinke,Diula KAGORO closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
MBANDJA 71 66 Banda,Gbaya,Ngbandi,Manja NGBANDI closest ethnicity within EA cluster (not in 'others' category in the Book)
TRISTAN 120 232 England NEWENGLAN 1st ethnicity within the EA cluster that appears in the book
YIRYORONT 233 641 Queensland WIKMUNKAN Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
YUNGUR 66 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi MUMUYE Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster

Note: from 16 ethnicity I could only fix 14.

juamiji1 commented 1 month ago

Nathan: Fill in the info with the most representative group (the first in the Ethnic cluster):

Atlas (v107) EA Cluster (v114) Berezkin code (oid) Berezkin group name Imputed ethnicity Reason
BRAZILIAN 117 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Discussed with Nathan
BAGIRMI 70 674 Sara SARA Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
CANTONESE 164 10024 Fujian Chinese MINCHINES Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
DJUKA 369 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Language based on Portuguese according to Murdock (1967) - book
SARAMACCA 369 10017 Portuguese PORTUGUES Language based on Portuguese according to Murdock (1967) - book
FUR 98 NA NA NA No other info available
GUATO 398 NA NA NA No other info available
HUTSUL 126 195 Czech UKRAINIANS First ethnicity in the EA cluster
IDOMA 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi NUPE First ethnicity in the EA cluster
IGALA 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi NUPE First ethnicity in the EA cluster
KORO 42 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi NUPE First ethnicity in the EA cluster
KURAMA 63 461 Manden,Bamana,Malinke,Diula KATAB First ethnicity in the EA cluster
MBANDJA 71 66 Banda,Gbaya,Ngbandi,Manja BWAKA First ethnicity in the EA cluster
TRISTAN 120 232 England NEWENGLAN First ethnicity in the EA cluster
YIRYORONT 233 641 Queensland WIKMUNKAN Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
YUNGUR 66 80 Tiv,Jukun,Mbete,Wute,Ekoi MUMUYE Only other ethnicity in the EA cluster
juamiji1 commented 1 month ago

Look at Missing values if ethnicities in cluster ID 279 (located in Greenland)