julianredmond / julianredmond.ca

The starter portfolio repository, basically empty, but with a few helper files.
https://angry-jackson-0923ea.netlify.com/pattern-library/#brand
0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer Evaluation - Melissa Lees #3

Open lees3 opened 4 years ago

lees3 commented 4 years ago

Great job Julian!! Below is my Peer Evaluation. It's been kept categorized so it is legible and easy to follow.

Effectiveness of the usability: Adding real content will help with the realness and clarity of your pattern library. Effectiveness of the message: The logo is great. Would love to see this type of style continued throughout your website once it's up! Quality of the project: I appreciate your reasoning for choosing your typeface- it's personalized and understandable. The header is nice and readable. Quality of the code: Are the cards meant to be the usual card shape? If so, maybe size them to be smaller and more contained. Adding more specific descriptions in your config files of how to use the cards and where they should be used around the site will help out with the clarity on how to use/build your site. Creativity: Love the colours and your logo!! The variation of they greys are nice with the vibrant pink/red colour. Also, really appreciate the hand-crafted style of the logo. Design execution: Looks great! One critique: Under the description for the primary colours, saying the colours are "subtle but bold" may be able to be reworked so the wording makes more sense. Maybe something like "bold yet cohesive", or something of the sort so it doesn't sound contradictory. Spelling & grammar: Looks good so far. Spelling will have to be re-checked once real content is added! I'll assist you with this.

Rubric:

0 points 1 points 2 points 3 points
Creativeness Bland, boring Fairly generic, but the colours are nice Good, works very well and is unique enough Wow! I never would have thought that would work so well!
Effectiveness I don’t know what this is trying to do The message isn’t completely clear and it’s difficult to use It’s obvious and simple to use The project is super effective and easy to use
Quality Non-existent Acceptable quality, more work could be done Good quality, up to the expectations of the teacher Stunning quality, this person rocks!
Effort Zero effort, incomplete Decent amount of effort Goodly amount of effort that shows Amazing, over-the-top amount of effort
Code quality Barely started Indentation is barely existent, lots of validation errors, very poor semantics Decent indentation, just a couple validation errors, decent semantics Well indented, fully valid, good semantics

13/15