jupyter / governance

The governance process and model for Project Jupyter
https://jupyter.org/governance/index.html
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
82 stars 71 forks source link

CoC: Adding a list of violating actions #70

Open choldgraf opened 5 years ago

choldgraf commented 5 years ago

In working on #69 , I found that the Turing Way CoC had a useful list of unnacceptable behaviors and some consequences:

https://github.com/alan-turing-institute/the-turing-way/blob/master/CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md#22-unacceptable-behaviour

I found this to be a way of making the more abstract ideals of the CoC a little bit more concrete. I also found their list to be generally useful and complete.

What do people think about me copying that section, with minimal changes, from the Turing Way CoC into the Jupyter CoC?

For reference, here is the full text of the section:


2.2 Unacceptable Behaviour

Examples of unacceptable behaviour by Turing Way community members at any project event or platform include:

2.3 Consequences of Unacceptable Behaviour

Participants who are asked to stop any inappropriate behaviour are expected to comply immediately. This applies to all Turing Way community events and platforms, either online or in-person. If a participant engages in behaviour that violates this Code of Conduct, any member of the core development team may warn the offender, ask them to leave the event or platform (without refund), or impose any other appropriate sanctions (see the enforcement manual for details).

damianavila commented 5 years ago

What do people think about me copying that section, with minimal changes, from the Turing Way CoC into the Jupyter CoC?

I am +1 on this but highlighting these are not the only cases. We want to cover other unacceptable behaviours that are not described in that section, IMHO.

choldgraf commented 5 years ago

@damianavila I totally agree with you that this isn't an exhaustive list. Perhaps rather than trying to define all of the different kinds of unacceptable behavior, we should just add in a sentence explicitly saying "this is an incomplete list, and specific examples are given as guidance for the kind of behavior we do not tolerate, as opposed to an exhaustive list."

damianavila commented 5 years ago

"this is an incomplete list, and specific examples are given as guidance for the kind of behavior we do not tolerate, as opposed to an exhaustive list."

Sounds great to me.