Closed choldgraf closed 3 years ago
@choldgraf I think this looks great! I didn't find anything that I wanted to suggest an edit to. I didn't read through all the text, but found a lot of what I read very good. I think for example you did an excellent job in the about page giving a far more friendly introduction than the much more technical one that was around before.
For anyone else looking at this PR; don't miss out on readthedocs PR review feature that gives you a link in the commit checks!
This is a nice PR that implements a lot of issues which is great. It moves content and its adds new content. This makes it hard to see which is which. I'll try and leave a comment on things which I think are new content to call attention to it.
It would be nice to get some feedback on https://github.com/jupyterhub/binderhub/issues/1091 as part of this docs rewrite. I think all documentation that isn't specific to mybinder.org should migrate to the BinderHub documentation.
OK I believe that I've addressed all of the comments here - improved a bunch of the language per your suggestions and also added redirects for all of the moved pages with sphinxext.rediraffe
.
@betatim I added some comments to the issue about moving the user docs to /binderhub
...I think it could be a good idea! Perhaps something we can continue tackling after this round of improvements? I'm happy to keep iterating in the next few weeks.
Great work on this everyone! 🥳😍
Hey all, anything else for me to do on this one? (and independent of this one, another note that @betatim is looking for feedback in https://github.com/jupyterhub/binderhub/issues/1091 on whether to combine the BinderHub user docs with the BinderHub admin docs)
I see lots of 👍 and 🚀 and "approve"s, but nobody has pressed the green button!
Thank you for your work om this @choldgraf and everyone for your review help! I love to see these kinds of improvements, but they are a bit scary to merge so i didnt do it myself before - i do think its important to help the PR authors move onwards though so i hit merge now - thanks for nudging with a comment!
thanks @consideRatio!
This is a medium-sized restructuring and update of the Binder user documentation. It has the following aims:
would love to hear thoughts! (cc @sgibson91 who helpfully opened several of the issues this tris to tackle...let me know if I missed something!)