justLV / onju-voice

A hackable AI home assistant platform
MIT License
1.31k stars 71 forks source link

Antenna choice? #7

Closed eabase closed 8 months ago

eabase commented 1 year ago

How's the antenna performance on this design? I'm asking because it seem a bit strange choice for using such a low gain antenna.

The one specified in your current design datasheet say that the gain is: -0.5 dBi, which is very bad. I would rather suggest something using uFL connector with a gain of at least a 2.0 dBi. Maybe something like:

justLV commented 1 year ago

I found the antenna has worked well enough for me even with uncompressed audio.

I did a crude throughput test comparing to an ESP32-S3 devboard with a uFL and didn't see any significant difference. (Also a uFL is a little more thought and testing to get into the form factor with minimal edits to the shell)

Improvements I made to the board were around 40MHz crystal stability which made a massive difference and I haven't had any issues since.

Re: component choice, I chose it mostly due to familiarity and being easy to source. I saw the Ignion antennas in a few products but haven't tried them. There's also the NN01-102.

You're also comparing the peak gain of the ignion to the average gain of the Johannson.

Would you like to design in the NN02-101?