Closed jwzimmer-zz closed 2 years ago
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Five Factor Model/ Big Five
Comparing our list of adjectives to the bipolar adjectives listed in table 2 of L. R. Goldberg. The development of markers for the big-five factor structure. Psychological Assessment, 4:26–42, 1992 (https://projects.ori.org/lrg/PDFs_papers/Goldberg.Big-Five-Markers-Psych.Assess.1992.pdf).
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago 
Shared words: {'active', 'adventurous', 'apathetic', 'assertive', 'bold', 'cautious', 'cold', 'cooperative', 'creative', 'curious', 'deep', 'disorganized', 'emotional', 'flexible', 'imaginative', 'independent', 'intellectual', 'kind', 'objective', 'passive', 'practical', 'provincial', 'quarrelsome', 'relaxed', 'reserved', 'rude', 'selfish', 'serious', 'shallow', 'spontaneous', 'subjective', 'uncreative', 'warm'}
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago | Character Adjectives | Overlap | Goldberg FFM Adj | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | passive | unenvious |
| 1 | artistic | flexible | intellectual |
| 2 | individualist | intellectual | undependable |
| 3 | repetitive | bold | agreeable |
| 4 | indiscreet | adventurous | uncooperative |
| 5 | joyful | serious | placid |
| 6 | western | shallow | rude |
| 7 | street-smart | warm | energetic |
| 8 | genuine | quarrelsome | demonstrative |
| 9 | backdoor | active | extravagant |
| 10 | existentialist | creative | uninquisitve |
| 11 | decisive | spontaneous | unadventurous |
| 12 | cool | cautious | emotional |
| 13 | family-first | rude | volatile |
| 14 | villainous | kind | unemotional |
| 15 | indulgent | objective | economical |
| 16 | patriotic | assertive | inhibited |
| 17 | atheist | provincial | nervous |
| 18 | insecure | subjective | wasteful |
| 19 | juvenile | practical | disorganized |
| 20 | classical | reserved | flexible |
| 21 | involved | imaginative | quarrelsome |
| 22 | reclusive | cold | selfish |
| 23 | quitter | uncreative | timid |
| 24 | anarchist | emotional | polite |
| 25 | helpless | apathetic | adventurous |
| 26 | hipster | curious | suggestible |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | cooperative | enthusiastic |
| 28 | ivory-tower | deep | creative |
| 29 | unassuming | independent | compliant |
| 30 | hypocritical | disorganized | conscientious |
| 31 | dunce | relaxed | objective |
| 32 | genius | selfish | subjective |
| 33 | tall | unimaginative | |
| 34 | crazy | cold | |
| 35 | scientific | talkative | |
| 36 | dorky | unintellectual | |
| 37 | unambitious | lethargic | |
| 38 | leisurely | generous | |
| 39 | gossiping | demanding | |
| 40 | scandalous | perceptive | |
| 41 | anxious | unsociable | |
| 42 | specialist | independent | |
| 43 | sane | sophisticated | |
| 44 | ferocious | relaxed | |
| 45 | extreme | passive | |
| 46 | judgemental | bold | |
| 47 | patient | rash | |
| 48 | high-tech | frivolous | |
| 49 | unlucky | sociable | |
| 50 | plays hard | uninhibited | |
| 51 | demonic | organized | |
| 52 | hurried | active | |
| 53 | down to earth | undemanding | |
| 54 | foolish | unsophisticated | |
| 55 | arrogant | unreliable | |
| 56 | deviant | imperturbable | |
| 57 | studious | stubborn | |
| 58 | respectful | kind | |
| 59 | passive | thrifty | |
| 60 | slacker | assertive | |
| 61 | bold | provincial | |
| 62 | mighty | envious | |
| 63 | disreputable | uncreative | |
| 64 | rational | thorough | |
| 65 | regular | considerate | |
| 66 | active | unkind | |
| 67 | edgy | trustful | |
| 68 | blue-collar | imperceptive | |
| 69 | industrial | cooperative | |
| 70 | submissive | fretful | |
| 71 | proper | deep | |
| 72 | irrelevant | careless | |
| 73 | chatty | inconsiderate | |
| 74 | liberal | dependable | |
| 75 | charming | serious | |
| 76 | sheriff | high-strung | |
| 77 | precise | shallow | |
| 78 | goof-off | distrustful | |
| 79 | orange | warm | |
| 80 | no-nonsense | spontaneous | |
| 81 | jock | cautious | |
| 82 | monochrome | impractical | |
| 83 | hard | silent | |
| 84 | resigned | peaceful | |
| 85 | physical | unintelligent | |
| 86 | equitable | ignorant | |
| 87 | reasonable | unselfish | |
| 88 | conspiracist | reserved | |
| 89 | methodical | practical | |
| 90 | fresh | imaginative | |
| 91 | funny | reliable | |
| 92 | deranged | apathetic | |
| 93 | competent | knowledgeable | |
| 94 | dramatic | curious | |
| 95 | varied | fearful | |
| 96 | communal | intelligent | |
| 97 | confidential | unconscientious | |
| 98 | warm | cultured | |
| 99 | well behaved | stingy | |
| 100 | mysterious | ||
| 101 | spontaneous | ||
| 102 | creepy | ||
| 103 | pessimistic | ||
| 104 | biased | ||
| 105 | zany | ||
| 106 | flamboyant | ||
| 107 | mild | ||
| 108 | prestigious | ||
| 109 | kinky | ||
| 110 | lenient | ||
| 111 | suspicious | ||
| 112 | sporty | ||
| 113 | cheery | ||
| 114 | aloof | ||
| 115 | philosophical | ||
| 116 | driven | ||
| 117 | salacious | ||
| 118 | bourgeoisie | ||
| 119 | debased | ||
| 120 | hesitant | ||
| 121 | apprentice | ||
| 122 | expressive | ||
| 123 | decorative | ||
| 124 | trash | ||
| 125 | honorable | ||
| 126 | cruel | ||
| 127 | head in clouds | ||
| 128 | avant-garde | ||
| 129 | noob | ||
| 130 | playful | ||
| 131 | political | ||
| 132 | open to new experiences | ||
| 133 | emotional | ||
| 134 | soft | ||
| 135 | jealous | ||
| 136 | heroic | ||
| 137 | reasoned | ||
| 138 | feminist | ||
| 139 | vague | ||
| 140 | democratic | ||
| 141 | domestic | ||
| 142 | scrub | ||
| 143 | queer | ||
| 144 | crafty | ||
| 145 | disorganized | ||
| 146 | selfish | ||
| 147 | flexible | ||
| 148 | tasteful | ||
| 149 | accepting | ||
| 150 | impartial | ||
| 151 | orderly | ||
| 152 | demure | ||
| 153 | penny-pincher | ||
| 154 | close-minded | ||
| 155 | persistent | ||
| 156 | chaste | ||
| 157 | devout | ||
| 158 | creative | ||
| 159 | sensible | ||
| 160 | spicy | ||
| 161 | feminine | ||
| 162 | open | ||
| 163 | proletariat | ||
| 164 | purple | ||
| 165 | pro | ||
| 166 | rich | ||
| 167 | astonishing | ||
| 168 | slugabed | ||
| 169 | eloquent | ||
| 170 | metaphorical | ||
| 171 | wholesome | ||
| 172 | drop out | ||
| 173 | young | ||
| 174 | independent | ||
| 175 | abstract | ||
| 176 | empirical | ||
| 177 | relaxed | ||
| 178 | frugal | ||
| 179 | luddite | ||
| 180 | beta | ||
| 181 | stinky | ||
| 182 | work-first | ||
| 183 | egalitarian | ||
| 184 | depressed | ||
| 185 | master | ||
| 186 | thick-skinned | ||
| 187 | socialist | ||
| 188 | poor | ||
| 189 | monastic | ||
| 190 | low-tech | ||
| 191 | assertive | ||
| 192 | masculine | ||
| 193 | right-brained | ||
| 194 | social | ||
| 195 | strict | ||
| 196 | nihilist | ||
| 197 | obsessed | ||
| 198 | human | ||
| 199 | mathematical | ||
| 200 | explorer | ||
| 201 | serious | ||
| 202 | official | ||
| 203 | shallow | ||
| 204 | heathen | ||
| 205 | cosmopolitan | ||
| 206 | overspender | ||
| 207 | traitorous | ||
| 208 | stylish | ||
| 209 | real | ||
| 210 | mad | ||
| 211 | eastern | ||
| 212 | modern | ||
| 213 | cautious | ||
| 214 | country-bumpkin | ||
| 215 | alpha | ||
| 216 | messy | ||
| 217 | lowbrow | ||
| 218 | tame | ||
| 219 | careful | ||
| 220 | builder | ||
| 221 | straight | ||
| 222 | practical | ||
| 223 | angelic | ||
| 224 | idealist | ||
| 225 | traditional | ||
| 226 | simple | ||
| 227 | weird | ||
| 228 | alert | ||
| 229 | gendered | ||
| 230 | mainstream | ||
| 231 | night owl | ||
| 232 | sheeple | ||
| 233 | compersive | ||
| 234 | vanilla | ||
| 235 | mature | ||
| 236 | intellectual | ||
| 237 | good-humored | ||
| 238 | moderate | ||
| 239 | disarming | ||
| 240 | happy | ||
| 241 | soulless | ||
| 242 | humorless | ||
| 243 | insider | ||
| 244 | extraordinary | ||
| 245 | loyal | ||
| 246 | whimsical | ||
| 247 | literary | ||
| 248 | obedient | ||
| 249 | clumsy | ||
| 250 | resolute | ||
| 251 | awkward | ||
| 252 | confident | ||
| 253 | rude | ||
| 254 | straightforward | ||
| 255 | fast | ||
| 256 | coordinated | ||
| 257 | moody | ||
| 258 | interesting | ||
| 259 | legit | ||
| 260 | skeptical | ||
| 261 | complimentary | ||
| 262 | pacifist | ||
| 263 | conservative | ||
| 264 | cunning | ||
| 265 | barbaric | ||
| 266 | first-mate | ||
| 267 | adventurous | ||
| 268 | tense | ||
| 269 | hoarder | ||
| 270 | optimistic | ||
| 271 | lustful | ||
| 272 | politically correct | ||
| 273 | tactful | ||
| 274 | sexist | ||
| 275 | authoritarian | ||
| 276 | refined | ||
| 277 | objective | ||
| 278 | nerd | ||
| 279 | subjective | ||
| 280 | ugly | ||
| 281 | competitive | ||
| 282 | thick | ||
| 283 | hedonist | ||
| 284 | bitter | ||
| 285 | pack rat | ||
| 286 | wise | ||
| 287 | high IQ | ||
| 288 | calm | ||
| 289 | sober | ||
| 290 | chaotic | ||
| 291 | feisty | ||
| 292 | transient | ||
| 293 | extrovert | ||
| 294 | lewd | ||
| 295 | self-disciplined | ||
| 296 | puny | ||
| 297 | generalist | ||
| 298 | focused on the present | ||
| 299 | mundane | ||
| 300 | captain | ||
| 301 | poisonous | ||
| 302 | neurotypical | ||
| 303 | scholarly | ||
| 304 | brave | ||
| 305 | kind | ||
| 306 | armoured | ||
| 307 | instinctual | ||
| 308 | meek | ||
| 309 | civilized | ||
| 310 | provincial | ||
| 311 | highbrow | ||
| 312 | multicolored | ||
| 313 | miserable | ||
| 314 | outsider | ||
| 315 | rugged | ||
| 316 | fortunate | ||
| 317 | bright | ||
| 318 | scruffy | ||
| 319 | cooperative | ||
| 320 | deep | ||
| 321 | urban | ||
| 322 | modest | ||
| 323 | incompetent | ||
| 324 | spiritual | ||
| 325 | oblivious | ||
| 326 | statist | ||
| 327 | introspective | ||
| 328 | mischievous | ||
| 329 | vengeful | ||
| 330 | bookish | ||
| 331 | roundabout | ||
| 332 | introvert | ||
| 333 | repulsive | ||
| 334 | permanent | ||
| 335 | charismatic | ||
| 336 | reserved | ||
| 337 | imaginative | ||
| 338 | impatient | ||
| 339 | animalistic | ||
| 340 | apathetic | ||
| 341 | forgiving | ||
| 342 | rigid | ||
| 343 | vain | ||
| 344 | thin | ||
| 345 | androgynous | ||
| 346 | unprepared | ||
| 347 | morning lark | ||
| 348 | slovenly | ||
| 349 | technophile | ||
| 350 | private | ||
| 351 | complicated | ||
| 352 | libertarian | ||
| 353 | direct | ||
| 354 | valedictorian | ||
| 355 | tiresome | ||
| 356 | autistic | ||
| 357 | ludicrous | ||
| 358 | lazy | ||
| 359 | short | ||
| 360 | resistant | ||
| 361 | altruistic | ||
| 362 | intimate | ||
| 363 | not introspective | ||
| 364 | pronatalist | ||
| 365 | resourceful | ||
| 366 | treasure | ||
| 367 | humble | ||
| 368 | unpolished | ||
| 369 | rough | ||
| 370 | sickly | ||
| 371 | angry | ||
| 372 | utilitarian | ||
| 373 | vulnerable | ||
| 374 | worldly | ||
| 375 | attractive | ||
| 376 | outlaw | ||
| 377 | workaholic | ||
| 378 | formal | ||
| 379 | unorthodox | ||
| 380 | pure | ||
| 381 | quarrelsome | ||
| 382 | unpatriotic | ||
| 383 | go-getter | ||
| 384 | realist | ||
| 385 | focused on the future | ||
| 386 | sarcastic | ||
| 387 | uninspiring | ||
| 388 | literal | ||
| 389 | emancipated | ||
| 390 | arcane | ||
| 391 | conventional | ||
| 392 | sheltered | ||
| 393 | shy | ||
| 394 | cringeworthy | ||
| 395 | minimalist | ||
| 396 | cold | ||
| 397 | unambiguous | ||
| 398 | manicured | ||
| 399 | diligent | ||
| 400 | guarded | ||
| 401 | soulful | ||
| 402 | smooth | ||
| 403 | logical | ||
| 404 | sad | ||
| 405 | inspiring | ||
| 406 | sorrowful | ||
| 407 | racist | ||
| 408 | wild | ||
| 409 | slothful | ||
| 410 | important | ||
| 411 | healthy | ||
| 412 | stoic | ||
| 413 | glad | ||
| 414 | nonpolitical | ||
| 415 | trusting | ||
| 416 | works hard | ||
| 417 | average | ||
| 418 | child free | ||
| 419 | uncreative | ||
| 420 | self-conscious | ||
| 421 | dominant | ||
| 422 | quiet | ||
| 423 | loud | ||
| 424 | rural | ||
| 425 | theist | ||
| 426 | pretentious | ||
| 427 | deliberate | ||
| 428 | enslaved | ||
| 429 | basic | ||
| 430 | city-slicker | ||
| 431 | neat | ||
| 432 | bossy | ||
| 433 | soft 2 | ||
| 434 | lavish | ||
| 435 | concrete | ||
| 436 | gregarious | ||
| 437 | rebellious | ||
| 438 | remote | ||
| 439 | wavering | ||
| 440 | slow | ||
| 441 | impulsive | ||
| 442 | sweet | ||
| 443 | nurturing | ||
| 444 | beautiful | ||
| 445 | low IQ | ||
| 446 | normal | ||
| 447 | left-brained | ||
| 448 | stable | ||
| 449 | historical | ||
| 450 | self-assured | ||
| 451 | innocent | ||
| 452 | old | ||
| 453 | cryptic | ||
| 454 | curious | ||
| 455 | gracious | ||
| 456 | sensitive | ||
| 457 | scheduled | ||
| 458 | theoretical | ||
| 459 | insulting | ||
| 460 | codependent |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Script for comparing lists of adjectives, outputting a Venn diagram and a markdown or latex table listing the sets of words and their overlap, saved in --> https://github.com/jwzimmer/tv-tropening/commit/c24f941be97581af1ea54b46ef1816b81428f816
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Adjectives associated with NEO-PI-R facets from table 1 of https://darkwing.uoregon.edu/~sanjay/pubs/bigfive.pdf
| Character Adjectives | Overlap | NEO-PI-R Facet Adjectives | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | shy | not self-confident |
| 1 | artistic | artistic | artistic |
| 2 | individualist | forgiving | not contented |
| 3 | repetitive | curious | wide interests |
| 4 | indiscreet | adventurous | adventurous |
| 5 | joyful | moody | tense |
| 6 | western | imaginative | sociable |
| 7 | street-smart | tense | enthusiastic |
| 8 | genuine | warm | not careless |
| 9 | backdoor | warm | |
| 10 | existentialist | not show-off | |
| 11 | decisive | forceful | |
| 12 | cool | organized | |
| 13 | family-first | not impulsive | |
| 14 | villainous | outgoing | |
| 15 | indulgent | excitable | |
| 16 | patriotic | sympathetic | |
| 17 | atheist | energetic | |
| 18 | insecure | not lazy | |
| 19 | juvenile | shy | |
| 20 | classical | not stubborn | |
| 21 | involved | moody | |
| 22 | reclusive | efficient | |
| 23 | quitter | irritable | |
| 24 | anarchist | imaginative | |
| 25 | helpless | unconventional | |
| 26 | hipster | not demanding | |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | thorough | |
| 28 | ivory-tower | forgiving | |
| 29 | unassuming | curious |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Adjectives selected by 10 psychologists to represent FFM in John 1990, from table 1 of https://darkwing.uoregon.edu/~sanjay/pubs/bigfive.pdf
| Character Adjectives | Overlap | FFM Adjectives chosen by 10 Psychologists | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | logical | cruel |
| 1 | artistic | deliberate | artistic |
| 2 | individualist | cruel | undependable |
| 3 | repetitive | artistic | narrow interests |
| 4 | indiscreet | adventurous | clever |
| 5 | joyful | bossy | responsible |
| 6 | western | shallow | touchy |
| 7 | street-smart | tense | retiring |
| 8 | genuine | warm | friendly |
| 9 | backdoor | active | noisy |
| 10 | existentialist | cautious | sympathetic |
| 11 | decisive | anxious | energetic |
| 12 | cool | kind | resourceful |
| 13 | family-first | civilized | moody |
| 14 | villainous | resourceful | dignified |
| 15 | indulgent | shy | emotional |
| 16 | patriotic | assertive | gentle |
| 17 | atheist | trusting | unemotional |
| 18 | insecure | stable | good-natured |
| 19 | juvenile | moody | withdrawn |
| 20 | classical | practical | original |
| 21 | involved | reserved | nervous |
| 22 | reclusive | imaginative | quarrelsome |
| 23 | quitter | cold | adventurous |
| 24 | anarchist | emotional | witty |
| 25 | helpless | precise | affectionate |
| 26 | hipster | simple | tense |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | forgiving | enthusiastic |
| 28 | ivory-tower | dominant | forceful |
| 29 | unassuming | wise | temperamental |
| 30 | hypocritical | calm | conscientious |
| 31 | dunce | curious | anxious |
| 32 | genius | sensitive | irresponsible |
| 33 | tall | cooperative | worrying |
| 34 | crazy | quiet | praising |
| 35 | scientific | quarrelsome | spunky |
| 36 | dorky | shy | |
| 37 | unambitious | ingenious | |
| 38 | leisurely | disorderly | |
| 39 | gossiping | cold | |
| 40 | scandalous | talkative | |
| 41 | anxious | wise | |
| 42 | specialist | calm | |
| 43 | sane | outspoken | |
| 44 | ferocious | generous | |
| 45 | extreme | foresighted | |
| 46 | judgemental | helpful | |
| 47 | patient | inventive | |
| 48 | high-tech | sophisticated | |
| 49 | unlucky | logical | |
| 50 | plays hard | sharp-witted | |
| 51 | demonic | frivolous | |
| 52 | hurried | contented | |
| 53 | down to earth | sociable | |
| 54 | foolish | organized | |
| 55 | arrogant | show-off | |
| 56 | deviant | active | |
| 57 | studious | insightful | |
| 58 | respectful | outgoing | |
| 59 | passive | unfriendly | |
| 60 | slacker | kind | |
| 61 | bold | civilized | |
| 62 | mighty | assertive | |
| 63 | disreputable | trusting | |
| 64 | rational | despondent | |
| 65 | regular | precise | |
| 66 | active | thorough | |
| 67 | edgy | dominant | |
| 68 | blue-collar | self-punishing | |
| 69 | industrial | unkind | |
| 70 | submissive | cooperative | |
| 71 | proper | quiet | |
| 72 | irrelevant | self-pitying | |
| 73 | chatty | careless | |
| 74 | liberal | deliberate | |
| 75 | charming | unstable | |
| 76 | sheriff | planful | |
| 77 | precise | polished | |
| 78 | goof-off | wide interests | |
| 79 | orange | dependable | |
| 80 | no-nonsense | high-strung | |
| 81 | jock | bossy | |
| 82 | monochrome | shallow | |
| 83 | hard | warm | |
| 84 | resigned | pleasant | |
| 85 | physical | forgetful | |
| 86 | equitable | cautious | |
| 87 | reasonable | silent | |
| 88 | conspiracist | unintelligent | |
| 89 | methodical | commonplace | |
| 90 | fresh | soft-hearted | |
| 91 | funny | fault-finding | |
| 92 | deranged | stable | |
| 93 | competent | efficient | |
| 94 | dramatic | unselfish | |
| 95 | varied | reserved | |
| 96 | communal | practical | |
| 97 | confidential | imaginative | |
| 98 | warm | painstaking | |
| 99 | well behaved | reliable | |
| 100 | mysterious | simple | |
| 101 | spontaneous | forgiving | |
| 102 | creepy | appreciative | |
| 103 | pessimistic | curious | |
| 104 | biased | fearful | |
| 105 | zany | sensitive | |
| 106 | flamboyant | intelligent | |
| 107 | mild | thankless | |
| 108 | prestigious | hard-hearted | |
| 109 | kinky | stern | |
| 110 | lenient | slipshot | |
| 111 | suspicious | stingy | |
| 112 | sporty | ||
| 113 | cheery |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Page 37, Table 1, from The Measurement of Meaning (book) by Osgood, Suci, and Tannenbaum (1957)
| Character Adjectives | Overlap | Adjectives, page 37, Osgood et al 1957 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | passive | treble |
| 1 | artistic | fresh | sick |
| 2 | individualist | sad | cruel |
| 3 | repetitive | cruel | green |
| 4 | indiscreet | shallow | happy |
| 5 | joyful | happy | white |
| 6 | western | tense | short |
| 7 | street-smart | short | angular |
| 8 | genuine | active | light |
| 9 | backdoor | slow | yellow |
| 10 | existentialist | sweet | small |
| 11 | decisive | poor | large |
| 12 | cool | beautiful | clear |
| 13 | family-first | brave | fast |
| 14 | villainous | healthy | unpleasant |
| 15 | indulgent | rich | agitated |
| 16 | patriotic | fast | sacred |
| 17 | atheist | kind | blue |
| 18 | insecure | ugly | rough |
| 19 | juvenile | ferocious | soft |
| 20 | classical | cold | nice |
| 21 | involved | rough | rounded |
| 22 | reclusive | soft | strong |
| 23 | quitter | rugged | weak |
| 24 | anarchist | thick | valuable |
| 25 | helpless | bitter | wide |
| 26 | hipster | thin | stale |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | old | near |
| 28 | ivory-tower | calm | tasty |
| 29 | unassuming | bright | awful |
| 30 | hypocritical | hard | tense |
| 31 | dunce | young | honest |
| 32 | genius | loud | empty |
| 33 | tall | deep | rich |
| 34 | crazy | relaxed | narrow |
| 35 | scientific | smooth | ugly |
| 36 | dorky | ferocious | |
| 37 | unambitious | bland | |
| 38 | leisurely | cold | |
| 39 | gossiping | thick | |
| 40 | scandalous | bitter | |
| 41 | anxious | bass | |
| 42 | specialist | black | |
| 43 | sane | fair | |
| 44 | ferocious | calm | |
| 45 | extreme | worthless | |
| 46 | judgemental | dry | |
| 47 | patient | young | |
| 48 | high-tech | full | |
| 49 | unlucky | relaxed | |
| 50 | plays hard | smooth | |
| 51 | demonic | passive | |
| 52 | hurried | profane | |
| 53 | down to earth | sad | |
| 54 | foolish | pungent | |
| 55 | arrogant | clean | |
| 56 | deviant | active | |
| 57 | studious | poor | |
| 58 | respectful | brave | |
| 59 | passive | healthy | |
| 60 | slacker | kind | |
| 61 | bold | red | |
| 62 | mighty | sharp | |
| 63 | disreputable | cowardly | |
| 64 | rational | rugged | |
| 65 | regular | dishonest | |
| 66 | active | fragrant | |
| 67 | edgy | bright | |
| 68 | blue-collar | hard | |
| 69 | industrial | wet | |
| 70 | submissive | loud | |
| 71 | proper | deep | |
| 72 | irrelevant | long | |
| 73 | chatty | delicate | |
| 74 | liberal | far | |
| 75 | charming | dark | |
| 76 | sheriff | unfair | |
| 77 | precise | fresh | |
| 78 | goof-off | hot | |
| 79 | orange | shallow | |
| 80 | no-nonsense | foul | |
| 81 | jock | bad | |
| 82 | monochrome | dull | |
| 83 | hard | sour | |
| 84 | resigned | pleasant | |
| 85 | physical | slow | |
| 86 | equitable | sweet | |
| 87 | reasonable | peaceful | |
| 88 | conspiracist | dirty | |
| 89 | methodical | beautiful | |
| 90 | fresh | low | |
| 91 | funny | hazy | |
| 92 | deranged | high | |
| 93 | competent | heavy | |
| 94 | dramatic | thin | |
| 95 | varied | old | |
| 96 | communal | distasteful | |
| 97 | confidential | good | |
| 98 | warm |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Page 67, Table 6, from The Measurement of Meaning (book) by Osgood, Suci, and Tannenbaum (1957)
| Character Adjectives | Overlap | Adjectives, page 67, Osgood et al 1957 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | passive | uneven |
| 1 | artistic | deliberate | diffuse |
| 2 | individualist | sad | violent |
| 3 | repetitive | shallow | green |
| 4 | indiscreet | happy | busy |
| 5 | joyful | varied | happy |
| 6 | western | tense | strange |
| 7 | street-smart | active | familiar |
| 8 | genuine | slow | steady |
| 9 | backdoor | feminine | angular |
| 10 | existentialist | beautiful | light |
| 11 | decisive | rich | annoying |
| 12 | cool | fast | powerful |
| 13 | family-first | masculine | repeated |
| 14 | villainous | ugly | small |
| 15 | indulgent | cold | large |
| 16 | patriotic | rough | safe |
| 17 | atheist | mild | clear |
| 18 | insecure | soft | fast |
| 19 | juvenile | rugged | rumbling |
| 20 | classical | simple | unpleasant |
| 21 | involved | thin | pulling |
| 22 | reclusive | bright | dangerous |
| 23 | quitter | hard | rough |
| 24 | anarchist | loud | soft |
| 25 | helpless | deep | uncertain |
| 26 | hipster | relaxed | gliding |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | smooth | gentle |
| 28 | ivory-tower | rounded | |
| 29 | unassuming | weak | |
| 30 | hypocritical | easy | |
| 31 | dunce | wide | |
| 32 | genius | calming | |
| 33 | tall | tense | |
| 34 | crazy | loose | |
| 35 | scientific | empty | |
| 36 | dorky | hollow | |
| 37 | unambitious | feminine | |
| 38 | leisurely | rich | |
| 39 | gossiping | narrow | |
| 40 | scandalous | solid | |
| 41 | anxious | subtle | |
| 42 | specialist | ugly | |
| 43 | sane | colorless | |
| 44 | ferocious | cold | |
| 45 | extreme | tight | |
| 46 | judgemental | scraping | |
| 47 | patient | resting | |
| 48 | high-tech | dry | |
| 49 | unlucky | full | |
| 50 | plays hard | relaxed | |
| 51 | demonic | smooth | |
| 52 | hurried | passive | |
| 53 | down to earth | sad | |
| 54 | foolish | active | |
| 55 | arrogant | clean | |
| 56 | deviant | colorful | |
| 57 | studious | red | |
| 58 | respectful | masculine | |
| 59 | passive | sharp | |
| 60 | slacker | obvious | |
| 61 | bold | rugged | |
| 62 | mighty | bright | |
| 63 | disreputable | hard | |
| 64 | rational | wet | |
| 65 | regular | loud | |
| 66 | active | whining | |
| 67 | edgy | deep | |
| 68 | blue-collar | delicate | |
| 69 | industrial | fluttering | |
| 70 | submissive | careless | |
| 71 | proper | pleasing | |
| 72 | irrelevant | even | |
| 73 | chatty | dark | |
| 74 | liberal | definite | |
| 75 | charming | deliberate | |
| 76 | sheriff | hot | |
| 77 | precise | intense | |
| 78 | goof-off | labored | |
| 79 | orange | shallow | |
| 80 | no-nonsense | varied | |
| 81 | jock | concentrated | |
| 82 | monochrome | bad | |
| 83 | hard | dull | |
| 84 | resigned | pleasant | |
| 85 | physical | slow | |
| 86 | equitable | dirty | |
| 87 | reasonable | beautiful | |
| 88 | conspiracist | low | |
| 89 | methodical | hazy | |
| 90 | fresh | pushing | |
| 91 | funny | mild | |
| 92 | deranged | high | |
| 93 | competent | heavy | |
| 94 | dramatic | simple | |
| 95 | varied | thin | |
| 96 | communal | exciting | |
| 97 | confidential | complex | |
| 98 | warm | good | |
| 99 | well behaved |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago Comparing trait adjectives versus the union of these lists (3 relating to FFM, 2 from Measurement of Meaning)
| Character Adjectives | Overlap | Adjectives from FFM and MoM | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | open-minded | cruel | treble |
| 1 | artistic | artistic | sick |
| 2 | individualist | intellectual | artistic |
| 3 | repetitive | happy | intellectual |
| 4 | indiscreet | short | undependable |
| 5 | joyful | rude | violent |
| 6 | western | fast | green |
| 7 | street-smart | resourceful | happy |
| 8 | genuine | moody | familiar |
| 9 | backdoor | rough | not careless |
| 10 | existentialist | emotional | angular |
| 11 | decisive | soft | retiring |
| 12 | cool | disorganized | friendly |
| 13 | family-first | quarrelsome | excitable |
| 14 | villainous | selfish | large |
| 15 | indulgent | flexible | uncooperative |
| 16 | patriotic | adventurous | clear |
| 17 | atheist | tense | safe |
| 18 | insecure | creative | rude |
| 19 | juvenile | feminine | fast |
| 20 | classical | anxious | moody |
| 21 | involved | rich | extravagant |
| 22 | reclusive | objective | uninquisitve |
| 23 | quitter | shy | unadventurous |
| 24 | anarchist | subjective | dignified |
| 25 | helpless | ugly | blue |
| 26 | hipster | ferocious | uncertain |
| 27 | stick-in-the-mud | cold | volatile |
| 28 | ivory-tower | thick | gentle |
| 29 | unassuming | bitter | rounded |
| 30 | hypocritical | wise | withdrawn |
| 31 | dunce | calm | inhibited |
| 32 | genius | young | strong |
| 33 | tall | independent | valuable |
| 34 | crazy | relaxed | timid |
| 35 | scientific | smooth | wide |
| 36 | dorky | passive | polite |
| 37 | unambitious | logical | adventurous |
| 38 | leisurely | sad | suggestible |
| 39 | gossiping | bold | tasty |
| 40 | scandalous | active | tense |
| 41 | anxious | poor | forceful |
| 42 | specialist | brave | honest |
| 43 | sane | healthy | temperamental |
| 44 | ferocious | kind | empty |
| 45 | extreme | provincial | conscientious |
| 46 | judgemental | civilized | hollow |
| 47 | patient | assertive | anxious |
| 48 | high-tech | trusting | worrying |
| 49 | unlucky | masculine | praising |
| 50 | plays hard | uncreative | objective |
| 51 | demonic | precise | narrow |
| 52 | hurried | rugged | subjective |
| 53 | down to earth | dominant | ugly |
| 54 | foolish | bright | ingenious |
| 55 | arrogant | hard | ferocious |
| 56 | deviant | cooperative | colorless |
| 57 | studious | quiet | bland |
| 58 | respectful | deep | talkative |
| 59 | passive | loud | thick |
| 60 | slacker | deliberate | bitter |
| 61 | bold | fresh | wise |
| 62 | mighty | serious | lethargic |
| 63 | disreputable | shallow | black |
| 64 | rational | bossy | fair |
| 65 | regular | varied | calm |
| 66 | active | warm | outspoken |
| 67 | edgy | spontaneous | foresighted |
| 68 | blue-collar | slow | helpful |
| 69 | industrial | cautious | sophisticated |
| 70 | submissive | sweet | passive |
| 71 | proper | beautiful | profane |
| 72 | irrelevant | stable | bold |
| 73 | chatty | practical | rash |
| 74 | liberal | reserved | sociable |
| 75 | charming | imaginative | uninhibited |
| 76 | sheriff | mild | active |
| 77 | precise | simple | unsophisticated |
| 78 | goof-off | apathetic | clean |
| 79 | orange | forgiving | unreliable |
| 80 | no-nonsense | thin | outgoing |
| 81 | jock | old | stubborn |
| 82 | monochrome | curious | unfriendly |
| 83 | hard | sensitive | brave |
| 84 | resigned | kind | |
| 85 | physical | thrifty |
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago ^If we want to compare anything else we can use this script.
jwzimmer-zz
commented
2 years ago I found a big list of Person-Describing adjectives so figured I'd check those.
Downloaded the PDAs from: https://dataverse.harvard.edu/dataset.xhtml;jsessionid=6d5ecdcf358283613bff9d05919a?persistentId=doi%3A10.7910%2FDVN%2FGHYMEV&version=&q=&fileTypeGroupFacet=%22Text%22&fileAccess=
One concern is that the adjectives in our list of traits were specifically chosen to represent a certain model, e.g. the Big Five. This might make seeing a similar structure unremarkable. (In more words: devil's advocate: we don't know where the openpsychometrics guy got the adjective pairs he used... if he got them from a questionnaire specifically designed to measure FFM or NEO or one of these other models then does that make it uninformative that some similar-looking dimensions emerge? devil's devil's advocate: not all of the traits are high magnitude in the first few dimensions -- some of them are near 0 -- if these words were picked specifically from something intended to reflect a specific model similar to what we're seeing, I would think there wouldn't be any such traits?)
Note: none of this has been addressed in the draft, including adding the relevant citations.