jxjo / Xoptfoil-JX

Xoptfoil-JX - modified version
GNU General Public License v3.0
14 stars 5 forks source link

Feature request: minimum-cp constraint or penalty #34

Closed klausbu closed 5 months ago

klausbu commented 5 months ago

Feature request:

Is there a way to set minimum-cp (from the xflr OpPoint view F5) as a constraint or penalty to be above a certain value (maybe for a defined AOA range)?

This can be relevant for wings, stabilizers... operating under water.

jxjo commented 5 months ago

(Xoptfoil-JX development ended --> please go to Xoptfoil2)

Hello,

Could you explain a little what you like to achieve (or the use case)?

Is it to limit the suction peak? In this case - as the suction peak depends mainly on the leading edge curvature - it would be most easy to limit the curvature at leading edge ...

regards

Jochen

klausbu commented 5 months ago

Hello Jochen,

There has been a discussion about it and its implementation related to the original xoptfoil but the implementation never happened:

See: https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?2095696-XoptFoil-airfoil-optimization-with-XFoil/page29 #431, #432

The limitation of the suction peak is one aspect but the cp-min can also be above the back of the foil, in this case a "rooftop" can be a result, see picture under #432 on the very right.

regards,

Klaus

PS: Should be move the discussion to Xoptfoil2 ?

jxjo commented 5 months ago

Hello Klaus,

... yes - would you be so kind and move the issue to Xoptfoil2?

Meanwhile I'll have a look at rcgroups ...

regards Jochen

jxjo commented 5 months ago

moved to Xoptfoil2