search

k-int / gokb-phase1

Original GOKb repo - Moving to https://github.com/openlibraryenvironment/gokb
http://www.gokb.org
Other
11 stars 5 forks source link

Title with 2 ISSNs, one that does not exist in Live #531

Closed jhsolomon closed 7 years ago

jhsolomon commented 8 years ago

Title : 21804731 - Acta Endocrinologica has two different ISSNs.

Namespace ID Actions issnl 0300-9750 Delete issn 0300-9750 Delete issn 2053-4175 Delete

The 0300-9750 matches the ISSN in Live, but 2053-4175 does not seem to match anything. Can you see where this identifier is coming from?

ianibbo commented 8 years ago

Sure,

this is the line from the issn-l file

xab:0300-9750 0300-9750 2053-4175

issn-l is telling us that 0300-9750 is also 2053-4175 - does that make sense, or am I incorrectly interpreting?

basically, we load this line and create a title entry "Unknown Title 0300-9750" with these identifiers

Later on, we load the title data from live, and we work out that the actual title is "Acta Endocrinologica" so we change the title we assigned ("Unknown Title 0300-9750") for the better one, leaving us with a title containing the identifiers from the issn-l and the proper title from live.

Sounds OK?

Ian Ibbotson Director Knowledge Integration Ltd 35 Paradise Street, Sheffield. S3 8PZ T: 0114 273 8271 M: 07968 794 630 W: http://www.k-int.com Doodle: http://doodle.com/ianibbo

On 14 September 2016 at 19:43, jhsolomon notifications@github.com wrote:

Title : 21804731 - Acta Endocrinologica has two different ISSNs.

Namespace ID Actions issnl 0300-9750 Delete issn 0300-9750 Delete issn 2053-4175 Delete

The 0300-9750 matches the ISSN in Live, but 2053-4175 does not seem to match anything. Can you see where this identifier is coming from?

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/k-int/gokb-phase1/issues/531, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAfzdTo2Od30GjZod4f-q-Z721uBP_CXks5qqEBCgaJpZM4J9Gt5 .

ianibo commented 8 years ago

J can you see if this is OK to be closed? ta.

jhsolomon commented 8 years ago

Just to make sure I understand, will the incorrect ISSN 2053-4175 then be removed from the record?

On Fri, Sep 16, 2016 at 3:05 AM, Ian Ibbotson notifications@github.com wrote:

Assigned #531 https://github.com/k-int/gokb-phase1/issues/531 to @jhsolomon https://github.com/jhsolomon.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/k-int/gokb-phase1/issues/531#event-791734889, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMwAJa3mcSzG5dXpBqXfgwJ1AuDSPlamks5qqj-hgaJpZM4J9Gt5 .

Jennifer Solomon GOKb Editor, Acquisitions and Discovery North Carolina State University Libraries 919-515-2743 j kristen_wilson@ncsu.eduhsolomo@ncsu.edu

ianibo commented 8 years ago

Yep, thats right, but lets wait until I've run the housekeeping on test then we can review properly. WIll mark for retest once thats done

jhsolomon commented 8 years ago

There are still two versions of this title record.

This one is correct: https://gokb-test.openlibraryfoundation.org/gokb/resource/show/org.gokb.cred.JournalInstance%3A21804731#identifiers

This one still has the strange ISSN: https://gokb-test.openlibraryfoundation.org/gokb/resource/show/org.gokb.cred.JournalInstance%3A3829949#identifiers

jhsolomon commented 7 years ago

Acta Endocrinologica still contains an incorrect ISSN. https://gokb-test.openlibraryfoundation.org/gokb/resource/show/org.gokb.cred.JournalInstance%3A3829949#identifiers

image

http://gokb.openlibraryfoundation.org/gokb/resource/show/org.gokb.cred.TitleInstance%3A65608#identifiers

jhsolomon commented 7 years ago

Closing issue, per discussion with Ian about ISSN-L.