kabouzeid / Phonograph

A material designed music player for Android
GNU General Public License v3.0
2.73k stars 731 forks source link

Feature Request: Could it split the artist when a song with multiple artists. #151

Open Dolanting opened 7 years ago

Dolanting commented 7 years ago

It combined the artists when songs have multiple artists, this cause the artist tab lose bio and picture. So could you find a better solution to deal with this issue? I suggest to split the artist when a song appear with multiple artists.

arkon commented 6 years ago

I personally don't like this as no music player I've ever seen does this, and it's generally not how music is tagged.

taugimo commented 5 years ago

Sorry to comment on such an old issue, but how should I tag songs with multiple artists and multiple genres to be shown correctly? There are a lot of encoders but just a few players which support cutting at a semicolon 🤔🤔

bwalsh0 commented 4 years ago

This doesn't seem to be fixed yet, but many protocols such as Windows Explorer, Windows Media Player, and more use ' / ' as a delimiter for multiple artists, for example:

A song with the artist tag Madeon / Porter Robinson would be displayed under both Madeon and Porter Robinson, and the song would list the artists as Madeon, Porter Robinson.

Note the space before and after the '/', so artists such as AC/DC wouldn't be affected. Perhaps a non-default option in settings would keep both groups of users satisfied.

Additional standardized delimiters include ;, |.

jerrac commented 1 year ago

Can we add a semi-colon ; as a delimiter as well? I have tons of songs from when I used MediaMonkey that list multiple artists per song with that delimiter. Like Artist1;Artist2 would then (as @bwalsh0 said) make the song show up under both artists.

Thanks!