Open Kherby opened 6 years ago
I gave up on the router and sold it on Amazon and bought a Linksys Velop AC6600 three node system to replace the broken WRT3200ACM wifi.
There is more wrong with the mwlwifi than ESP and Intel card compatibility.
Once I switched, performance has been tenfold better all the time, plus each node can be directly wired -:)
On Sun, Jan 13, 2019, 09:45 tiagogaspar8 <notifications@github.com wrote:
@makedir https://github.com/makedir I have already spent too much money on this router and every other device achieves very high speeds in wireless so I'd rather replace the wireless card on my PC with another one. Intel has been nagging me with this issue as I don't answer fast enough and they want to solve this issue as fast as possible. Now, I need to know if this problem we're all having is with the intel driver or with the mwlwifi firmware. Maybe the Intel driver has a bug that other AP's "ignore" and mwlwifi just can't deal with it and forces those sudden drops (?) I'm willing to test anything @yuhhaurlin https://github.com/yuhhaurlin wants to help fix everything.
— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/kaloz/mwlwifi/issues/307#issuecomment-453840201, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ARIphLv9ALGBHgBWBmEApz6lELLNtNQsks5vC1R-gaJpZM4VCdMd .
fwiw, I have Intel 9260 clients running just fine off 5Ghz (Windows 10)
@diizzyy really? I'll be thinking about buying that card. Thanks!
So hard to read? I said the opposite: https://github.com/kaloz/mwlwifi/issues/307#issuecomment-406100552
@makedir Different radios, WRT1200AC vs WRT3200ACM
So I guess this problem will never be fixed?
So I guess this problem will never be fixed?
Correct. I advice you to sell the WRT3200, then buy a WRT1200 (you get them really cheap, it has the same CPU power than the 3200), and then buy a stand alone access point.
the wrt3200 has a higher cpu clock speed
If you are just going to sell the WRT3200 you might as well get a low-power x86 base with ath10k AP's
@makedir Different radios, WRT1200AC vs WRT3200ACM
I have both the WRT1200 and WRT3200. Although they have different radios - both WIFI suck really hard. I always had issues with the 1200 and thought with an upgrade to WRT3200 all problems will disappear. Haha ROFL. The wifi of WRT3200 is even worse! I could not believe it. This damn router has 2 additional antennas and performs so badly. It was a true downgrade. Haha, a downgrade from a troublesome WRT1200. One could call it disaster.
@yuhhaurlin any updates about this issue?
@yuhhaurlin any updates about this issue?
lol. How many times? It wont get fixed. Do yourself a favor and buy a standlone AP, something like a Ubiquiti https://www.amazon.de/Ubiquiti-Networks-2-4GHz-867Mbit-UAP-AC-LITE/dp/B016K4GQVG/ref=sr_1_4?__mk_de_DE=%C3%85M%C3%85%C5%BD%C3%95%C3%91&keywords=access+point&qid=1556321813&s=gateway&sr=8-4
I see what you mean, but I already bought this router, It works so well for me, there are no routers in the market that perform as well as this one besides this Intel issue, at least for the same price, so I'm here to hep whoever is building this driver to fix it. I would do it myself but I ave no idea how to....
PS: @yuhhaurlin I don't know if I should be saying this to you or to @kaloz but there seems to be a issue with the WMM queues in that some of them are swapped, and that makes that priorities aren't correctly assigned (?) As I've said before I'm willing to make the needed tests to solve these issues.
It works so well for me,
lel. Dont you see your mistake here? You even gave yourself the correct answer. Never buy a router with build in wifi.
That's what I've been telling people; go out and buy an AP if wifi isn't working well. The router functions with OpenWrt are worth it alone without WiFi. IMHO, Linksys should just sell a powerful Wrt router without Wifi, and let people buy a separate AP.
Funny stuff since AP's are the same as wireless router's hardware wise (actually APs typically have lower specs). You can turn any wireless router into an AP just put all interfaces (eth and wlan) onto the same bridge interface.
Funny stuff since AP's are the same as wireless router's hardware wise (actually APs typically have lower specs). You can turn any wireless router into an AP just put all interfaces (eth and wlan) onto the same bridge interface.
Nope, "theyre not". I am speaking about a "REAL AP", not some bogus fake AP from the typical moron companies ala Netgear, D-Link(lel) ect. I gave already an example, Ubiquiti.
The difference here is, that companies like Ubiquiti need to be competent, Netgear and co not, because just being consumer products. They have no need to bring out a working product including software/drivers.
The difference also is, that wifi module differ in the chip, broadwell, Intel, Qualcomm, Marvel. And sadly, Marvel is just trash for the driver part. That is just how it i.
Has anyone noticed 30% ram usage on wrt3200 by mwlwifi like in this issue #152? I noticed ~ 150 Mb memory usage by mwlwifi. Do you have any suggestions/recommendations?
For what it's worth, I had been suffering with an Intel 7260 wifi chip in my ultrabook for something like two years now with my WRT3200ACM and performance going back and forth between really fast and dial up speeds. It would always scale in between those speeds without much reasoning and the wireless channels would also randomly disappear. Meanwhile, all of the other 10-12 wireless devices in the house had zero issues with connectivity or speed. So just recently I decided to look more into wireless chipsets and do some research.
I finally decided to pick up a cheap Atheros QCA9377 wireless chip from Amazon for $20 and swap out the Intel chip for this one quite easily with the underside of my ultrabook. The suffering ended immediately.
My first reaction after 10-15 minutes of web browsing was "Wow, so this is what the Internet is like!!! "This is what I have been missing out on while using mwlwifi connected to a device with an Intel wireless chipset".
Huge difference. And the Atheros QCA9377, by specifications, is slower in comparison to the Intel 7260 chip. Yet, when it comes to whacky incompatibilities and bugs like the mess that is mwlwifi, specifications on paper do not always equal real world performance. Seriously, the difference is like night and day. If anybody has a wireless chipset that mwlwifi does not get along with, it is worth doing a bit of research and finding another chipset. If you can't swap out a wireless chipset, you can look into USB wireless sticks which are a bit more money, but try to determine chipsets before purchasing because different hardware revisions can have different chipsets in some cases.
Anyway, I wanted to share my experience with mwlwifi and since I had some bit of success in the end, I decided to post this info here just in case it may be beneficial to others. Have a look at some of the Qualcomm Atheros wireless chipsets before dropping your mwlwifi router entirely.
@WildByDesign I agree on what you monitored about the Intel wifi card. Something is just wrong and broken with Intels Wifi drivers, since years. At least under Windows. I noticed Intel also releases a new Wiffi driver every 4-6 weeks and everytime I look into their changelog, there are like 10 changes for stability/performance, kinda a back and forth back and forth back and forth. Somehow they dont know what theyre doing, or the chip is kinda broken in hardware, and they try to fix it with workarounds, which just never work perfectly. They sadly have discotinued the development for the 7260 chip, and only newer ones are still developed. The 9260 works much better and has stable and better peformance, yet it still has its little hick ups sometimes.
Today i've noticed that websites were loading very slow when i was connected with my WRT3200acm. Iperf test shows again that something is wrong with the throughput.... This happens every day and i have to reconnect Wifi or restart the Interface to fix it. Also the general 5GHz Wifi performance is bad most of the time, same with 2.4GHz. The throughput is not stable for some reason, even when i'm very close to the Router...
Iperf test:
After restarting Wifi:
Test 1m away from the WRT3200acm:
Why is the speed dropping to ~30-40Mbps when i'm only 1m away from the AP ?? Why is this only happening with the WRT3200acm and not with my other Hardware ?? Is the wifi unit defective ?! Do i need to contact Linksys for a replacement ?? Or is it just the marvel driver causing this issues ? What can i do to fix the sloppy wifi performance ? Btw, im even using Linksys High Gain Antennas (WRT004ANT)... I'm using the latest Intel Wifi drivers and 5Ghz works just fine with my other Hardware... For example here is a test with my DIR-860L @ 5GHz: