search

karamba3d / K3D_NightlyBuilds

Nightly build versions of Karamba3d
https://karamba3d.com
25 stars 2 forks source link

BUG: Different utilisation results from the same component #83

Open jjsolly opened 1 month ago

jjsolly commented 1 month ago

Describe the bug Getting a different upper bound on utilisation from the Util output compared to the different util checks. See image attached. Unless I'm missing something this is not deliberate behaviour.

2024-07-11 16_44_21-Grasshopper - FMT_0432_Model01_Karamba_Rh8_rev2_

karamba3d commented 1 month ago

The contributions of normal force, bending moments and shear interact. This is why the extreme values of the individual utilization contributions of the cross section forces and moments do not correspond to the extreme values of the overall utilization. -- Clemens

jjsolly commented 1 month ago

Ah sorry Clemens. I had made the incorrect assumption that those combined checks were wrapped up into the individual contributions.

Like the new LCInd that shows which LC causes the max values, could we maybe request an output which shows which utilisation check gives the value output by Util?