search

karasevm / PrivateDNSAndroid

Quick settings tile to switch active private DNS server
MIT License
420 stars 47 forks source link

Sometimes after clicking on a tile nothing happens #7

Closed Artem13327 closed 2 weeks ago

Artem13327 commented 7 months ago

This is already the second similar application where I encounter this oddity, and I have to switch the private DNS settings in the settings and it seems to help It also happens that something seems to happen after a while, well, in general, I don’t know how to explain it

karasevm commented 7 months ago

Please provide more information: phone maker, model, android version. Also if you are able/willing to provide logs that would be very helpful as well.

Artem13327 commented 7 months ago

Android 11, I'll probably provide the logs a little later

njascgil commented 5 months ago

At first, I also tought that was the issue. But then it ocurred to me that it might be cycling through the DNS servers I had entered. After checking Android settings, that was indeed the case in my phone: pressing the tile cycles between servers, but only notifies when turning on, not when just changing to another server.

(edit july 2nd) I am adding a small video to illustrate the issue. Notice how a second tap on the tile (bottom left) does not trigger the banner (it should mention family.dns-adguard.com) even though the DNS is indeed changed underneath. Another small issue is also visible: note the "Off is off" when the DNS is turned off (maybe "Private DNS turned off" would be nicer).

https://github.com/karasevm/PrivateDNSAndroid/assets/12452486/9b552bf2-53e1-46e2-8811-d701062a9b1e

njascgil commented 4 months ago

With the latest version (1.7) the issue described in my previous post still appears on my Poco X5 Pro. Please let me know if I should try to provide more details or if it would be better to open a new issue.

karasevm commented 3 months ago

Sorry for taking so long to follow up. The screen recording was really useful, the messages that appear on top is something done by MIUI/HyperOS itself and is not something the app can control. You can enable icon labels to get the intended behavior by going into Settings -> Notifications & status bar and toggling off "Don't show icon labels".

karasevm commented 2 weeks ago

I'm closing this issue for now, if it comes back feel free to open a new one.