search

karthik / smb_git

A review paper describing how git can be used to improve reproducibility in science
85 stars 25 forks source link

Barriers to the use of git by scientists #6

Open yoavram opened 11 years ago

yoavram commented 11 years ago

Although I agree that:

the basic features of git can be readily used without any knowledge of command line tools

I don't think the command line is the greatest barrier for wider git use in academia. I think that it takes some time to wrap your head around the pull-edit-commit-edit-commit-...-push workflow and that merging, branching, forking and pull-requesting (not to mention cherry-picking, rebasing and other horrors) are not so simple. So I think there is a steep learning curve, but it can be mitigated with new online courses such as the one offered by code school and github.

yoavram commented 11 years ago

Also maybe half a paragraph on git gui and maybe even a screenshot? That readers will not be intimidated by the command line nature of the tool. Here's an example of git-gui on windows:

git-gui