search

kboghdady / youTube_ads_4_pi-hole

YouTube script to add the new Ads list for Pi-hole
2.43k stars 265 forks source link

How do you create the list? #32

Open kstka opened 4 years ago

kstka commented 4 years ago

Hi.

I have a guess that your list works for US mostly. Because as soos as I switch my youtube location and languege to US, I get much less ads than when Im "located" in Russia.

Could you please share the way you create the list? Then I will be able to create a Russian version for myself and finally get rid of ads.

Thanks

kboghdady commented 4 years ago

hi @kstka I will upload it in the next week or so.

kstka commented 4 years ago

Thanks, I will wait for it.

BTW I have tested it out for some more and I can say that your list works great for US, no ads at all

kboghdady commented 4 years ago

Thank you very much @kstka for your encouragement and feedback

nikeee commented 4 years ago

I'm also interested in the way of creating the list.

The current list does not work in Germany.

kboghdady commented 4 years ago

@nikeee I will try to upload it this weekend. I am sorry for the delay, but I have a crazy busy schedule these days

kstka commented 4 years ago

Sorry do disturb you, @kboghdady . Maybe you will find time to post your script\idea sooner or later. There is no problem if it is a draft, I can code it and sent it back to you.

I have tried this project https://github.com/foae/pihole-youtube-block , but it was totally blocking youtube. So the youtube ads problem is still relevant.

Thanks!

taogre commented 4 years ago

Hey, I'd be interested too. List does not seem to work for Switzerland...

nikeee commented 4 years ago

@kboghdady Any news on that?

crazyquark commented 4 years ago

Does not work for Romania

hajosattila commented 4 years ago

Nice work, but does not work for Hungary

bm1549 commented 4 years ago

I'm looking forward to this as well!

MarioGK commented 4 years ago

Any update on this issue?

ashleycawley commented 4 years ago

I'm in the UK and I'm interested in contributing to the list or this project in general, if I can help then please let me know.

franz-josef-kaiser commented 4 years ago

Opening up the way you generate the list, I might be able to set up a cron myself to fetch the list for Austria and push automated PRs.

mittus commented 4 years ago

My pihole hosted on Moscow, I use United States location for YouTube confifg, but seen Ukranian Ads. Installation youTube_ads_4_pi-hole don't resolve my problem. It only need installed pihole server in US?

sultanamoa commented 4 years ago

@kboghdady thanks for this list , as for UAE, & KSA this YouTube Ad blocking will note work because of Different servers for Different locations can you pleas share with us the Script that you are using to collect the ad DNS from the Pi logs so that i can filter my network traffic and share the list for Different contrary's ,

thanks My.zip

Snoopgtg commented 4 years ago

@kboghdady how it customize for any country?

sultanamoa commented 4 years ago

@kboghdady can you please share the script

RCH-9 commented 4 years ago

I'm currently trying foae/pihole-youtube-block to get the domain list from the logs. It appears to be working although the blocking is obviously retroactive as the ad has to be shown for its domain to appear in the logs.

zxqs commented 4 years ago

@RCH-9 can't we somehow crowd-source domain collection?

RCH-9 commented 4 years ago

@RCH-9 can't we somehow crowd-source domain collection?

I think I'm going to abandon trying to block via DNS, it's just too unreliable because ads and videos are served from the same domains. If you block ads, it's inevitable you will block videos as well.

franz-josef-kaiser commented 4 years ago

I believe @RCH-9 is searching for a way to make this a business model, so there's no chance that he will open up and crowd source list making. Guess we can drop out and abandon it here.

zxqs commented 4 years ago

@RCH-9 I might do the same, I'm just trying to avoid the hassle of setting up Kodi on a separate device and I kinda like the network wide blocking. I tried this list with US VPN and you're right, it's not really reliable, it blocks videos probably 7 out of ten times but also there are false positives and when it happens it is really annoying

RCH-9 commented 4 years ago

I believe @RCH-9 is searching for a way to make this a business model, so there's no chance that he will open up and crowd source list making. Guess we can drop out and abandon it here.

What on earth are you talking about? I simply made a list using the tool mentioned by kstka on March 1st and tried that. Like any DNS method for YT, it blocks ads but also blocks the videos. It's perfectly free for you to try yourself.

@RCH-9 I might do the same, I'm just trying to avoid the hassle of setting up Kodi on a separate device and I kinda like the network wide blocking. I tried this list with US VPN and you're right, it's not really reliable, it blocks videos probably 7 out of ten times but also there are false positives and when it happens it is really annoying

Yeah, the simple conclusion is DNS level blocking is possibly never going to work reliably because you can't block one without the other.

franz-josef-kaiser commented 4 years ago

@RCH-9 my apologies!

fugkco commented 3 years ago

@kboghdady any updates on this?