kcl-ddh / digipal

Digital Resource for and Database of Paleography, Manuscripts and Diplomatic
61 stars 15 forks source link

Meaning of Aspects and Appearance #48

Closed kabikaj closed 3 years ago

kabikaj commented 4 years ago

I don't find any documentation about the meaning and usage of Aspects and Appearance under Descriptor. I would like to know if they may be useful for my case.

stewartbrookes commented 4 years ago

Hi! Thanks for your question. From what I remember, when we first developed the database, we'd intended to use Aspects to comment on the "look" of the handwriting, e.g. elongated, slanted, compressed, and Appearance was for the stylistic appearance, e.g. scribbled, transitional, glossed, square. But we ended up not using Aspects and Appearance. We "misused" Aspects in the Models of Authority project to add the function "Position" (but that's a fudge: ideally, we would have added an official option for Position to the database); for an example of that, see [Hi! Thanks for your question. From what I remember, when we first developed the database, we'd intended to use Aspects to comment on the "look" handwriting, e.g. elongated, slanted, compressed, and Appearance was for the stylistic appearance, e.g. scribbled, transitional, glossed, square. But we ended up not using Aspects and Appearance. We "misused" Aspects in the Models of Authority project to add the function "Position" (but that's a fudge: ideally, we would have added an official option for Position to the database); for an example of that, see http://www.modelsofauthority.ac.uk/digipal/search/facets/?sort=hi_date&_xp_position=1&img_is_public=1&locus=face&_st_position=c&position=Top+line&view=grid&result_type=graphs&page=1]. How would you like to use Aspects and Appearance? And what material are you working with?

Screenshot 2020-09-03 at 18 31 21

kabikaj commented 4 years ago

Hi! thank you so much for your fast reply! And sorry for taking a bit long to answer, I wanted to think if what you explained to me could be useful for us, but I don't think so. We built a classification with symbols and descriptors that seems to be working. Our material is in Arabic

pastokes commented 3 years ago

I'm closing this issue as it seems to have been answered and there has been no recent activity, but feel free to re-open if there is more to discuss.