Auto-Type entry choice popup doesn't remember ordering

[saladpanda]

Since i upgraded to KeepassXC 2.3 the ordering of matching entries in the Auto-Type popup changed. It is now ordering by the "Group" column in descending order (Z-A). If I change this to ascending order (or any other column) this setting is not saved for the next time.

It would be great if KeepassXC could remember my ordering setting again

Expected Behavior

KeepassXC should remember the ordering preference for the Auto-Type popup or (less intuitive) offer a setting for this.

Current Behavior

Auto-Type popup ordering always starts with "Group" in descending (Z-A) order.

Steps to Reproduce (for bugs)

1. Create multiple matching entries for a window/website
2. Call the Auto-Type popup using the configured keyboard shortcut

Context

I have my primary accounts in a group called "000main" and secondary accounts in groups with different names. Previously this made my primary accounts always be the first entry in the Auto-Type popup. Now they're always last.

Debug Info

KeePassXC - Version 2.3.1 Revision: 2fcaeea

Libraries:

• Qt 5.6.1
• libgcrypt 1.8.1

Operating system: Ubuntu 16.04.4 LTS CPU architecture: x86_64 Kernel: linux 4.4.0-116-generic

Enabled extensions:

• Auto-Type
• Browser Integration
• Legacy Browser Integration (KeePassHTTP)
• SSH Agent
• YubiKey

[TheZ3ro]

Before 2.3 it was remembering the last order? Seems that the new AutoTypeAssociation model doesn't implement that

[saladpanda]

Just tested again with KeepassXC 2.2.4. It also does not remember the last order. But the default order is "Group" ascending (A-Z) which I think makes more sense than descending.

Easy fix for me: I'll rename my 000main Group to ZZZmain

[Dasmark]

I have the same issue. Not only does it not save the last sort order, but also i would expect to sort it by Group, then Title and lastly Username. In fact, the order seems to be totally random and I always have to search my entry.

[mruessler]

I found that the order for my entries is by entry creation date. I am using 2.3.4. All shown entries are in the same group and have the same prefix. Did something change?

[mruessler]

Following up on my previous comment: Can I permanently change the order in the auto-type window?

[droidmonkey]

I do not think so.

[MmAtBosch]

Please fix this issue 🙏🏻 i have many of autotype entries for specific applications and it is always a mess to find the correct entry in the auto-type popup.

Would be so thankful!

[droidmonkey]

Recommend reading the user guide to see how to properly setup your entries to be used for auto-type. You shouldn't have to wade through hundreds of entries if properly setup with window associations.

[Dasmark]

@droidmonkey some people, like me, manage hundreds of accounts for certain games. There's simply no way to further reduce the number of entries shown in the list. For a certain game, I have about 400 of them, because I need one account per item mule character. Yes, that's a thing.

What's the problem with getting one of

• sorting the entries by groups, then username
• remembering the sort order
• having an option for the default sort order

It might not be a common issue, but the current sort order (date of creation) isn't what I would call an intuitive setting.

[droidmonkey]

It sorts by group name then by title by default. Does the search not work for you to narrow down your choice? You posted a long time ago, have you updated to 2.7.1?

[Dasmark]

It does not sort by title at all, only by group - on all versions since the issue was opened. And yes, I'm at 2.7.1. Does it sort like that for you? This is what the default is for me. The grayed-out text is identical, so not sorted by title.

Of course, searching works, and that's how I'm using it. All we're saying is, that It would be nice if it was sorting by group name, and then by title, because that's how it used to be and what makes most sense to us.

[droidmonkey]

Interesting should be sorting by title as well, must be using the "natural" list order instead.

[luddinho]

I feel the same way. The application is really great and it provides tons of excellent features. However, I cannot understand why such an essential setting is not possible for the user.

I am also wondering and I can not believe that the list per default is sorted by the creation date of the entries and connot be customized user specific.

In my use case I do not have hundreds of entries appearing in the auto type selection window as mentioned here, but I would also appreciate it to have this user-specific configuration option available. Either the setting will be rememberd from the last action or it can be configured by the user individually from the menu as option.

Please give this request a realistic chance as an improvement for future releases of the application.

[aetonsi]

Hi, is there a release date for v2.8?

[droidmonkey]

No and it won't be anytime soon