search

kendzi / kendzi3d

3D plugin for JOSM
57 stars 19 forks source link

Support crossings/passage routes/thoroughfare #80

Closed natrius closed 6 years ago

natrius commented 6 years ago

Hello,

i would like to tag a caste in 3d while checking with kendzi but i was not able to see a passage other than split the building in 3 parts and tag the middle-one with a min_height. The problem - thats not true. So i found this https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:3D-building/Durchfahrt wikisite and i like it, its simple, intuitive and there is no need to split the building. But unfortunately it does not show up in kendzi3d.

Usecases: Castle-Entrances Old towns, there are sometimes passes through buildings that are built wall to wall.

Is there already another tag-set that is used for that or is it not implemented yet?

Greets

kendzi commented 6 years ago

Sorry, it is not implemented at all. I don't known any 3D render for OSM which support it. I'm not sure even if that tagging schema is accepted as it may by only idea.

natrius commented 6 years ago

According to https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:tunnel tunnel=building_passage is approved and a used tag and is a valid usecase. The width, height is just there to clarify it. So, the only not approved tag would be passage_type= and would be just to clarify it further. I know a town where it is already often used and correctly tagged. Just the clarifying tags are missing. EDIT: Height and width is also in the key:tunnel tag suggested, maxheight= and maxwidth= and its not even wrong imho.