search

kennytv / list-of-shame

The List Of Shame, made by random people on the internet
https://kennytv.github.io/list-of-shame
378 stars 45 forks source link

Added AdvancedEnchantments #73

Open WillFP opened 3 years ago

WillFP commented 3 years ago

Added AdvancedEnchantments - the list of problems is so big that it would be longer than the entire rest of the readme

KaspianDev commented 2 years ago

Also mention that his website shows prices higher than even possible on spigot (to make discounts look even bigger)

also you cant review plugins on his site, or dislike other reviews (you can only like them, dislike button is not functioning)

WillFP commented 2 years ago

update: complaining in the discussion tab in competitors to AE, and has been for over 2 years now: feb 2020:

Screenshot 2022-01-27 at 14 36 09

jan 2022:

Screenshot 2022-01-27 at 14 36 34

Link: https://www.spigotmc.org/threads/eliteenchantments-%E2%9E%9C-create-your-own-enchantments-%E2%9A%9C%EF%B8%8F-web-panel-%E2%9A%9C%EF%B8%8F-190-premade-enchants-27-gkits.417799/page-10

this guy really is the bottom of the barrel

KaspianDev commented 2 years ago

change it from AE to GC. in general

WillFP commented 2 years ago

oh - and about the roman numeral code? yeah here's the stack overflow answer where he pasted the entire thing from - main method, class name, and all https://stackoverflow.com/a/9073310/11427550

Wesley51 commented 2 years ago

Wierd that a competitor would make this PR 🤔

WillFP commented 2 years ago

Competitor that doesn't have a 3000-line long switch statement

Wesley51 commented 2 years ago

oh - and about the roman numeral code? yeah here's the stack overflow answer where he pasted the entire thing from - main method, class name, and all https://stackoverflow.com/a/9073310/11427550

So what? All the class does is convert numbers... it doesn't contribute to the core functionality of the plugin. It would be a different story if he was reselling other plugin's code, which afaik is not the case. I don't see an issue here.

To me, this looks like you are using this public list to get more sales by getting people to believe your plugin is better. It's not right.

KaspianDev commented 2 years ago

oh - and about the roman numeral code? yeah here's the stack overflow answer where he pasted the entire thing from - main method, class name, and all https://stackoverflow.com/a/9073310/11427550

So what? All the class does is convert numbers... it doesn't contribute to the core functionality of the plugin. It would be a different story if he was reselling other plugin's code, which afaik is not the case. I don't see an issue here.

To me, this looks like you are using this public list to get more sales by getting people to believe your plugin is better. It's not right.

except his plugin is libre software

WillFP commented 2 years ago

oh - and about the roman numeral code? yeah here's the stack overflow answer where he pasted the entire thing from - main method, class name, and all https://stackoverflow.com/a/9073310/11427550

So what? All the class does is convert numbers... it doesn't contribute to the core functionality of the plugin. It would be a different story if he was reselling other plugin's code, which afaik is not the case. I don't see an issue here.

To me, this looks like you are using this public list to get more sales by getting people to believe your plugin is better. It's not right.

https://paste.willfp.com/hepeminaro.java the main class that controls all the effects is a gigantic switch statement