kepi / chromeEyeDropper

Eye Dropper and Color picker extension for Google Chrome
https://eyedropper.org
208 stars 73 forks source link

Rewritten Eye Dropper - testing and feedback needed #256

Closed kepi closed 1 week ago

kepi commented 2 weeks ago

I'm almost ready to publish rewrite of Eye Dropper with many fixes and UI improvements.

But as this is huge change, I would like to test it more and get some feedback. If you have time, please help me test it:

Beta version is now published at chrome store so it is enough to just add it as normal extension.

I'll gladly accept any feedback, bug reports etc. You can spam this issue or create new ones for specific troubles if not reported already.

NeonBeacon commented 2 weeks ago

Hi Kepi,

The functionality works well, although my intitial thought was that it hadn't worked.

The only potential critique for functionality would be to have that set as ticked as standard when someone installs the extension. But again, that might just be my preference rather than anything else.

The only other area I would mention, with a design background, only cosmetic, regarding the extension drop down frame,slightly rounded edges to the drop down box would be less harsh, and the font for the 'hex', 'code', 'rgb', 'hsl', 'hsv', 'New', 'Selected', 'Pick from', 'Hover over colors to preview a color in New square' and the 'linear-gradient' text could be prettier. But again, the cosmetics for such a good tool aren't that important.

kepi commented 2 weeks ago

Thanks for detailed walk through, it helps me rethink on my past decissions.

The only potential critique for functionality would be to have that set as ticked as standard when someone installs the extension. But again, that might just be my preference rather than anything else.

I'll probably go with your suggestion. My reasoning had been that I shouldn't rewrite content of user clipboard without his consent first, but that was many many years ago and I think it really adds to the confusion. Workaround would be some annoying popup which will tell on first use what to do, but I'll probably just set it as default.

The only other area I would mention, with a design background, only cosmetic, regarding the extension drop down frame,slightly rounded edges to the drop down box would be less harsh, and the font for the 'hex', 'code', 'rgb', 'hsl', 'hsv', 'New', 'Selected', 'Pick from', 'Hover over colors to preview a color in New square' and the 'linear-gradient' text could be prettier. But again, the cosmetics for such a good tool aren't that important.

Can you please give me screenshot how it looks like on your computer? IMHO fonts I'm using are OS specific, so I just want to check if it is looking too different from what I wanted.

NeonBeacon commented 1 week ago

image

Hi Kepi,

Here's the screenshot of how it looks on my PC

NeonBeacon commented 1 week ago

Sorry for the delay, couldn't get to my computer for a couple of days, I've posted on Github

On Tue, Jul 2, 2024 at 11:20 AM Kepi @.***> wrote:

Thanks for detailed walk through, it helps me rethink on my past decissions.

The only potential critique for functionality would be to have that set as ticked as standard when someone installs the extension. But again, that might just be my preference rather than anything else.

I'll probably go with your suggestion. My reasoning had been that I shouldn't rewrite content of user clipboard without his consent first, but that was many many years ago and I think it really adds to the confusion. Workaround would be some annoying popup which will tell on first use what to do, but I'll probably just set it as default.

The only other area I would mention, with a design background, only cosmetic, regarding the extension drop down frame,slightly rounded edges to the drop down box would be less harsh, and the font for the 'hex', 'code', 'rgb', 'hsl', 'hsv', 'New', 'Selected', 'Pick from', 'Hover over colors to preview a color in New square' and the 'linear-gradient' text could be prettier. But again, the cosmetics for such a good tool aren't that important.

Can you please give me screenshot how it looks like on your computer? IMHO fonts I'm using are OS specific, so I just want to check if it is looking too different from what I wanted.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/kepi/chromeEyeDropper/issues/256#issuecomment-2202661642, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A64BFCEVEEEMWA7IX25ZFO3ZKJ5FLAVCNFSM6AAAAABKF4EZPKVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDEMBSGY3DCNRUGI . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

kepi commented 1 week ago

@NeonBeacon that screenshot is definitely from old version :) Did you try it with extension loaded from zip?

Update: Chrome store already has latest beta: https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/eye-dropper-beta/ddepepfaephbkpjkhbjecikldgpnojjl

Anyway I'm reasonably sure it will work, so I'll try to upgrade prod version too when it is checked by chrome team.

NeonBeacon commented 1 week ago

Yep, I've now got the new version, all works, and it's looking good!

image

That was my mistake on the previous screenshot.

kepi commented 1 week ago

Great and thanks for confirmation. I published new version today for 10 % of users and I hope to gather bug reports if there is some problem, we will see. Thanks again for help.