search

keshavdv / unifi-cam-proxy

Enable non-Ubiquiti cameras to work with Unifi NVR
MIT License
1.73k stars 237 forks source link

Unifi protect version 4.0.33 update unifi-cam-proxy request because of no working live stream #383

Closed StijnMut closed 1 week ago

StijnMut commented 4 months ago

Camera

RTSP Stream Source

Firmware version of the camera

Protect version 4.0.33

Description

Since update 4.0.33 live streaming for 3rd party cameras doesnt work anymore over unifi-cam-proxy version 4.0.21 is the latest one that seems to still be in working order downgrading to 4.0.21 allows live streaming to be accessed but this makes the web interface unusable due to an error, can we find a way to update unifi-cam-proxy to protect version 4.0.33?

How to reproduce

Run protect version 4.0.33

Expected behaviour

No live stream just one image every 5-10 minutes

Screenshots

No response

Additional information

This is a kind of update request on the older version of protect the proxy works wonderfully

BenAChilds commented 4 months ago

I recently upgraded my UDM to a UDM Pro and immediately set out to use this project in order to integrate my non-Unifi cameras into Protect. I was disappointed when I found that I was experiencing the same behaviour though.

I have downgraded my Protect version to 4.0.21 though, and found that the behaviour still exists. All I get is the initial frame, then a loading indicator in the bottom left of each camera: image

This being the case, I'm not entirely convinced that this is related to differences between versions.

cefoster0 commented 4 months ago

My UDM is on the latest and it's still working with the branch that was mentioned in the other thread. It's slow but it eventually does load.

thomasdye12 commented 4 months ago

i have the same issue

jasoryeh commented 4 months ago

I identified a potential fix, playing with the flags on the container command, I found that Unifi Protect doesn't seem to like the aac reencoding flags. Using --ffmpeg-args="-c copy" seemed to work fine.

EDIT: might need to change the ffmpeg-args to copy all of the original args but change "-codec:a aac" to "-codec:a copy"

james3126 commented 4 months ago

I too am only able to get around 1 frame every few minutes when running the latest version of protect, and the dev build of the proxy to prevent constant broken pipe errors.

Unfortunately @jasoryeh suggestion to change the codec choice hasn't resolved the problem for me.

jasoryeh commented 4 months ago

I too am only able to get around 1 frame every few minutes when running the latest version of protect, and the dev build of the proxy to prevent constant broken pipe errors.

Unfortunately @jasoryeh suggestion to change the codec choice hasn't resolved the problem for me.

I've identified that the specific codec that seems to work is pcm_alaw, could you try using this flag on the command: -c:v copy -ar 32000 -ac 1 -codec:a pcm_alaw -b:a 32k

Others have tried, and it makes the live preview work on the web, only issue is the mobile app, when selecting an individual stream doesn't load (general live preview with multiple cameras appears to work).

The 1 frame every few minutes is from unifi-cam-proxy re-rendering a new image preview which appears to be a somewhat different process.

james3126 commented 4 months ago

I've just thrown that flag in and restarted the container. Still no live video. The "thumbnail" preview when highlighting the camera in the devices tab seems to update randomly every 2-10 seconds. I'm seeing fairly regular "broken pipe" and "ffmpeg process for videoX died" errors when attempting to view any live video even on the dev branch, which from what I gather from the other threads, isn't meant to be the case.

patrickbussmann commented 3 months ago

Hey guys - I found out that you need to use the newest Protect 4.1.39. Then it was working for me! Even without --ffmpeg-args.

james3126 commented 2 months ago

Hey guys - I found out that you need to use the newest Protect 4.1.39. Then it was working for me! Even without --ffmpeg-args.

Hello. I assume Protect version 4.1.39 is a beta/RC? I see 4.1.51 is the latest RC version on the UniFi forums now, so hopefully the fixes continue through to release. Fingers crossed!

cefoster0 commented 2 months ago

I'm on 4.1.53 and I no longer see events in my timeline. This possibly could be upgrading to frigate 0.14.1, perhaps the matt code needs to be updated.

given unifi's onvif roadmap, might be end of the road for this one.

wjdavis5 commented 1 month ago

Support for ONVIF hit my Dream Machine pro today. I was able to adopt my Reolink Duo 3 PoE.

stale[bot] commented 2 weeks ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.