Error in Keybase SigChain preventing Login

mr-mustash commented 3 years ago

Hey all, I've recently been unable to do many things in Keybase, this includes but is not limited to: logging in, retrieving files, cloning repos, and accessing my Stellar wallet.

I finally figured out something was wrong after getting my new phone and trying to sign in to my account. Upon attempting to log in I get the following message from the iOS App, Message wasn't signed. Error code 218: GENERIC in method keybase.1.login.login. I wanted to see if this was reproducible on one of my laptops so I logged out using the macOS GUI, tried to log back in, and got the exact same error.

After that I started to do some digging and found https://github.com/keybase/client/issues/3064 and https://github.com/keybase/client/issues/5378 which seemed to be the exact issue that I was having. I tried the following the recommendation other issues in that issue to to run keybase db nuke and that did not help my login errors.

Next I tried to force a login using the --paperkey flag and I had the same results:

$> keybase login --paperkey="f..."
▶ ERROR Message wasn't signed

Anyone will be able to reproduce this error if they even run id on my user:

$> keybase id king 
▶ ERROR Message wasn't signed

If anyone has any tips on how to unfuck my SigChain I would love to hear them. Thanks!

mr-mustash commented 3 years ago

More notes:

My keybase version

$> keybase --version 
keybase version 5.5.0-20200526170801+139bb348af

Other issues where this error has occurred due to SigChain issues

mr-mustash commented 3 years ago

Running keybase -d id king show exactly which signature is failing BTW.

2020-11-18T15:42:25.458533-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 131 Failing key----------
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.22 (Darwin)
Comment: GPGTools - https://gpgtools.org

mQINBFNIZzgBEADKOfkDAZQEPNBY0VUzLTpOBSoJhFi3+ibWgneiEF15nJiJ+sYx
QnGecfzZoQbLEkOx6m9gMNvdxY/D7z+uSFymCNHX5+04wWoIXezdU7UsW5MjJekL
G/grujADUW1v0dhr3psgl5M/WXtTQANu2TtHkj9GiY4BZR6MzFjmerwfsoVodNQs
GD+U1KsUDVzce8JSdugZ2paLcllhXLMtFlNc/1pqrW0tFNGLG4fbaQRpjF8uFLzv
5ccSWOX4CUd/uCmo7cYW90bnM8upjSc4xR5yydEwU4suURgqQslN8DGiiDYL02Aw
u7rWRDtVXk6+UovK58g6CbHdNqm+avupW8RkWQcxkSzo9g4BfbHpL+Z2tIjIUntI
nOZT04R5Mm8TUlDrxuQ7n4a7WCvmGzfofzofpyH1NFt9iZ10Nlk7tO/K4KGemCK4
S6rmYVb7Egypfl3C3vqa4z8tPQr8tO0KgJoFVQkcvc7wVU+OvUCiDeMpFg4mGhCo
AVqkzi4TW1D+5MpKxEtOh3KReCnV9CMtzgBFnL5zTssd6wsH5Y2wTUuHY8zHhkd0
Y9DuHky8Vd8tqMnIbWuSkOdcYuxIVOMh7xaNreNTQBFcM2mHLmZFFSkhvRTHacCD
ESWHT4eeiy2OF4/TnVcsyknwDSqSSXT+O1p1iA2IDnl4Nw716ZA2e6cOTQARAQAB
tCFrZXliYXNlLmlvL2tpbmcgPGtpbmdAa2V5YmFzZS5pbz6JAj0EEwEKACcFAlNI
ZzgCGy8FCRLMAwAFCwkIBwMFFQoJCAsFFgIDAQACHgECF4AACgkQKlkOyTX1XbF5
pg//eE93wAeYfhufyQpfLs6TBzSZqkTx1OVxXm2nJDHKrcD9zc+qw/lAicu+mnqt
Bvgzv7hgdVdJPLTmOiXUM5meEq/1+LRbtbYqgNU1AkpfFuJRhJVh+vwbbXrN8iCg
y8abT/7PnmOl+o+C5C1V/70RbZIu1o7RLdvPJvldONb9YqNxXHS+gngY5ZBXhSwf
XS7XXQH4kuoMbH3OkofRvo5RzNSbTiYoYwJno3KI7nxcUOZ1a0EYAxi6oHmDX7yS
Xiwm6HfPEHEj6RrLddOfe5C9eUIJsYbkdp1YQXGdEHHot1PBiUafwT2D6k1DAffs
eQjpXHC91c2iOTS2x1Hf5W/oTEmgyCrDXa6PYwzsIHe2ScNx98gXBBQPgKtTIrwK
YC4sSnAOFSlRdXkmjOOanByHPudSvDqWDQ6qr8YWWmf0hnHzi6lIMd3IyXXvyZJI
AEyQ1n+i6WQW3a0GOiAteH3L0wlVet7tOXtRfZ+oAwH21Tpi5wpc7DnIMtYtLcmK
WyecPpHOCKupBkECeSnysYAmiLr7WxCdKn1PUfm4XeQcLjOJu5OOQiIS42QOGZTV
7w/HJY7czqAwqOIhCv62fzueeQQpE0tPWlFlb8N9UrsokoiWAxTvy05j/Bf+CZtF
3ygHryR+nppQgNGalAGcgOvonTDD7tCDUDp0mAJ5qqTWpRG5Ag0EU0hnOAEQAJxt
F+gp8Cs0XZzYpElQ2mZ6eLoaK8pyWj8qaOJQ0ijgIUnOXqVpXKGDzDaI62sIlHms
y22P2OP7sdVxzfwYUTK7xGVIjzW+WAYRK2Ze536o9VKRk+RNgrrRHgOYpbTfmq6l
KZft3Bf5ytbqVXxHjqT/50v7r+geCPYh4e7SBEu7GuhCUaDKShwDs5uq8be4Uos+
hhU95mG2Fjxvz/5Daur1sIruIAHHFXptw18ozVRRY9Qy0IUtlHpceL3Fk+RoMdI0
27biZYoyMngJ/u4CzLT9zzQ/GhdJ+5m6MD6GgQmWQSz96rHs5s48FumjmtdchpYa
AOoXvtXkBbBq/lnRMPm/pR+9k0XuKMe3wBfq/AeVRtuvY/ZZsmFECcHl+nwIHE7h
EsmebWjKcz2coJe/+JexGjsdXIQcJ7w7XHzqFt9RNJWVmIq9hXWJko+coiq7GdWu
nZ6VfVgfnSNQFo8KpeqAbzGm+IRTFUZP3hw3arozkR4E4MebCy+4fo/5VMJ7l/qo
5/lm/PAK471TSdcEjyggzbx29J1nc0Jg++5sCTljJOl/SnA4vAeR45VZUaZ1BjEs
lbfx64gjEJUJsMCiofAdRyP5EAPMHCz0fOEmDiofwhqekY5326ZROQ1Xw/s1+t5U
D7KtM8PmdzgA1ChTjQKjFqG8oFnjONhDed/iRz+dABEBAAGJBEQEGAEKAA8FAlNI
ZzgCGy4FCRLMAwACKQkQKlkOyTX1XbHBXSAEGQEKAAYFAlNIZzgACgkQK1aTrhef
BcLmbhAAkLs7c8Lfoqcw7t66dLb9yOY+aLNQCl7X/tVibjt7+Qf9RYJXCaRXr34P
vFYqW6tlTf0VjDzZd4p3q1pVN0QLwrDZPpIwNoJIFpnLlUlFFLC2YN2XJwj1nmsJ
xSVG6qRkj+44c01J+lFgXt0riQG77gREbxuMdljCGezZsG3vqZDAyaXH2ACJkr4t
lZLIiLWEjSCCcGikYAtLx8UlHLrQxbeAe2AYEUOX1eGBCpoVwEEz8hRUSlhCs86k
BgSHoE3eVE+7MkEZnsfjTlUZynMtOMfNoRF82V7HHh9rBdXtEYedUUtsfbfCipwT
USToD5zBcqKJHjETAtisvW+SNrVmBMgXCueOr939u2CPy+6+XR9suxQM4w6ynQby
j8tlJ8ZWw9XFV27tdWj1CCpHi4OETQkBLswgmc+Gk5GaN01wftHB9lO3aa7VNxGL
VgnY4ZVwXHdDNyMDYlBytyZC2eylElbO1ndTaH9rUPVCTfL5ACSOJeBsysQmJ7Mf
brWqeXXJRNICQROuTqVCr3ve5Kh3yhXCIX7sqTKePbMX1K4ryxpnkmxU1Zu7vooF
kJ02CUKKOY7csrbRo+YEC3TcNxvtNJU0TA94HJMOh+VKZNbxtjsiSIE+Kkm1ReUh
/78aM4uT6ftthHO9g8HU1grlIhUv1FrpSvSFlkEYh6HqxMKJAu17thAAu6kkKusw
P2JUcvidbRmKuuuS/M3BwKJep6iH4FXukk/oKAXkU22Q3iFgGBW1hlRIhbc4yfCF
KpakfXA8lLfEjHvOgad41rw5Yaswc7QX4tiymA3B+T88/jGi+jPDojmzwZ0J0hfT
NFUH+nJ0nllTGPAbN/5OvNbn5+FSpmrmh9PRTV2ZbC/xqkmGDl1qitOyhjrtuHLh
zOJY+1f8+YAU//MJeW0Vp3K08IyXPFe/4W8heR9NTtxLAX0lLzoSZPhcJxiwt0wU
udbDerXjfqmwAjk3kaRIl2ARNft6KHYTLgysuOuH4hPgULN90wqAO+dyVgPkgJsK
e6U9LstkVfEQ1B/ZVszXHPy9/YWlziTjUGZQD6FwOUc6FC7bTvKefc1vbALS9WRv
U5ciSWpRTZ4HzoNqBept1bHfaq68YpePy1NueULzq/oxXdguhCfPbPevbKptqVm3
aH0/r94uX9t3gYsC+TPj6MH0zjsOIIR171+0B+4t2HZrA3VQM3IS8dJSSrjtAc6m
nPsFYgTYq8WdI4ua+kUOSFfiMgpMWUxcR/eiGUClo7WVrSEfmlbgG/bwtgd1LNhY
Yu/lqVVeqmZNqW/7rbdBwpiZQa20hZYvHeCpglkQhxHdRhYZRklHxay3PHiJtdS2
nYxIZrGhyACrG7B4CEea/fa2QCTUoRLVcfg=
=XOL2
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
2020-11-18T15:42:25.458907-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 132 Failing sig----------
-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: Keybase OpenPGP v0.1.5
Comment: https://keybase.io/crypto
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=JqTx
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459135-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 133 | Failure in VerifySigWithKeyFamily: Message wasn't signed [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459257-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 134 - verifySubchain -> false, ERROR: Message wasn't signed [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459375-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 135 - verifySigsAndComputeKeysCurrent for user 9f225787ae98779492b5235cb8480700 -> ERROR: Message wasn't signed [tags:ID2=DO2neICozm72,ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459498-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 136 - SigChainLoader#Load(9f225787ae98779492b5235cb8480700) -> (false, ERROR: Message wasn't signed) [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]

Full log id: 5653bfa8e0806f106c970a1c

keybase / client