Reddit can not be verified

keybase / keybase-issues

A single repo for managing publicly recognized issues with the keybase client, installer, and website.

900 stars 37 forks source link

Reddit can not be verified #3311

Open sdimkov opened 5 years ago

sdimkov commented 5 years ago

I'm unable to verify my Reddit account. I tried multiple times. Keybase fails at the last step (to verify my proof).

My Keybase profile My Reddit profile My proof post

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

Your post on reddit has no body, only a title. Here's an example of a working proof. What os, browser, and version of keybase did you use to make the post? I've sometimes seen the reddit form drop the body but thought we were using old.reddit. Will check it out. As a work around you could try clicking the body of the post before posting it.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

I just tried making a reddit proof and the link was to old reddit (https://old.reddit.com). Even on an account opted in to the redesign. Let me know if you're ending up on a form that's not on old reddit.

sdimkov commented 5 years ago

Yep you're right. The problem is most likely in the redesign. I didn't realize an actual body is needed, because when I followed the provided links, the pre-filled form had no body.

Now I opted out of the redesign and retried. It worked fine.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

The url Keybase shows you should be old.reddit.com which should punch through redesign preferences. So that's weird. But glad that worked for you.

ghost commented 5 years ago

The link says www.reddit.com when I hovered over the submit prefilled button. When I can post again in 7 minutes, I am going to try reposting using old.reddit.com and see if that works.

ghost commented 5 years ago

Using old.reddit.com works fine.

MasterGroosha commented 5 years ago

Why is this issue closed? I think there should be either a note on Keybase to use old.reddit.com or form template should be changed to support both designs.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

@SenorContento what platform and browser are you using @SenorContento that you saw www.reddit.com on hover? And what were you hovering over, was it in the Keybase app, website?

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

I should've read the timestamps on those messages... @MasterGroosha are you seeing a link to non-old reddit?

MasterGroosha commented 5 years ago

@mlsteele This link leads to https://www.reddit.com/r/KeybaseProofs/submit... And when I follow this link, "text" field is empty, even though URL has all the necessary text in it

ghost commented 5 years ago

@mlsteele I was using Chrome on Mac OSX.

racuna commented 5 years ago

Same problem, tried twice. And then tried again on the phone. No luck either.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

@racuna using the website not the app?

@racuna, @SenorContento what does "Reddit form prefilled" link to? Does any redirect happen after you click it?

racuna commented 5 years ago

mine: https://www.reddit.com/r/KeybaseProofs/comments/bemkg1/my_keybase_proof_redditracunix_keybaseracuna/

Thenk I switched to old reddit and worked.

user00265 commented 3 years ago

Well, I recently saw that my Reddit proof was no longer valid (post was still there), so I tried re-doing it... I have tried several times now and even though it looks like the others... it still doesn't work.

Keybase username: eresto Reddit username: user00265