search

keybase / keybase-issues

A single repo for managing publicly recognized issues with the keybase client, installer, and website.
900 stars 37 forks source link

All @facebook identity proofs showing as "unreachable", including my own #3556

Open reedriley opened 5 years ago

reedriley commented 5 years ago

When I click on the proofs; I'm taken to a correct looking identity proof on the user's Facebook profile. But within the Keybase app; all @facebook proofs are showing as "UNREACHABLE".

Reproduces on at least:

The CLI shows this error message:

"\<user>" on facebook failed: Could not find post text in Facebook's response (code=106)

I'm guessing something about the Facebook response changed, breaking client parsing?

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

Yep the Facebook response did change and we made 2 changes in the last few days to try to fix it. What users proofs show as unreachable? Feel free to send me the usernames via keybase chat if you'd prefer.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

I missed your "including my own". Your facebook proof likes like it's ✅ to me.

mlsteele commented 5 years ago

Talked out of band. Seems like checking facebook proofs over tor is broken for now due to captchas. A workaround is in our sights.

felixbuenemann commented 5 years ago

Thanks for the update, I think I'm running into the same issue.

The log shows that he post ist retrieved with status 200 OK, but the CSS selector doesn't match.

Using Keybase 4.5.0-20190919040131+93e889ab01 on macOS 10.14.6.

If I curl the post url directly it's fine, but through a tor proxy curl also gets a captcha.

So I think @mlsteele is on the right track.

pabru commented 5 years ago

Any update/ETA on this?

xaviablaza commented 4 years ago

Any updates on this issue? @mlsteele

McPringle commented 2 years ago

It's 2022 now and the problem is still the same. The Facebook identity is marked as unreachable but "View proof" works like a charm. The message is public and can be viewed when no user is logged in. Only when accessing using the Tor network, Facebook does not show the message and forwards to a login form instead. The check can't be done using the Tor network. It must be done via "public internet". An update on the status of this issue would be great.

My1 commented 2 years ago

same here. my FB Proof also looks broken on keybase but the URL checks out

the-reverend commented 5 months ago

same here. the proof is broken in keybase but the facebook post url is public and viewable even incognito in a browser.

mcg1969 commented 2 weeks ago

October 26, 2024 ... still true.