search

keymanapp / keyman

Keyman cross platform input methods system running on Android, iOS, Linux, macOS, Windows and mobile and desktop web
https://keyman.com/
Other
372 stars 102 forks source link

bug(android): sticky key previews #7510

Closed Runeboard closed 11 months ago

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug

When typing keys either side of the spacebar within the Keyman app, those keys stay large after being released instead of returning to normal.

Reproduce the bug

Please see the attached screen recording. About the first 50 seconds is showing how it should work. After that is a combination of showing the problem and how the rest of the keyboard responds as it should in spite of that problem.

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/115298797/197165746-a3394d98-69fd-4dec-86af-fcd756f6717a.mp4

Expected behavior

Keys should not remained enlarged after being released. They should return to normal size.

Related issues

No response

Keyman apps

Keyman version

Keyman for Android 15.0

Operating system

Android 11

Device

Unihertz Jelly 2

Target application

No response

Browser

No response

Keyboard name

Runeboard

Keyboard version

1.0

Language name

English (Runic)

Additional context

No response

mcdurdin commented 1 year ago

It's interesting that this appears to happen only on the bottom row. That may be significant.

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

It's interesting that this appears to happen only on the bottom row. That may be significant.

Also, it's only happening in the Keyman app itself, not in other apps where the Keyman keyboard is used.

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

We've had a couple of fixes included in 16.0 for clearing popup and subkeys. We aim to release that in the upcoming months.

mcdurdin commented 1 year ago

You can try Keyman for Android v16 at https://keyman.com/alpha :grin:

mcdurdin commented 1 year ago

@MakaraSok or @bharanidharanj could you try and reproduce this on 15.0.271 and then, if you can repro, try again on latest 16.0.x alpha?

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

This should be fixed in 15.0.272 by #7554

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

This should be fixed in 15.0.272 by #7554

I have version 15.0.273 on my phone and the problem is still present.

mcdurdin commented 1 year ago

@darcywong00 reopening for investigation

bharanidharanj commented 1 year ago

@MakaraSok or @bharanidharanj could you try and reproduce this on 15.0.271 and then, if you can repro, try again on latest 16.0.x alpha?

@mcdurdin Okay, I will retest it.

bharanidharanj commented 1 year ago

@mcdurdin Retested this with 15.0.271 build as well as in the 16.0.92-alpha build in my Android Mobile device (ver 11) and here is my observation: 1. Not able to reproduce the above issue in both the Keyman Versions. ie., pressing any key (especially with the bottom row keys) in the Runeboard (English) keyboard did not stick with the enlarge size. Seems to be working fine in both the Keyman versions. Thanks.

mcdurdin commented 1 year ago

Thanks @bharanidharanj. It seems that there is still an issue here as @Runeboard is still experiencing it. @Runeboard do you have a consistent way to reproduce the problem?

bharanidharanj commented 1 year ago

@darcywong00 Retested this with Keyman 17.0.20-alpha build in my Android Mobile device Version 11.0 and I was not able to reproduce the same. ie., Keys are not remaine enlarged after being released. (especially from the bottom row of the keyboard) . Seems to be working fine in the latest Keyman alpha build too. Thanks.

bharanidharanj commented 1 year ago

@mcdurdin @darcywong00 Today, I was able to see the issue (ie., sticky key preview) in the Android 11 / API 30 emulator. Here, What I did is: 1. I used the Keyman Keyboard as the System Keyboard and opened Chrome browser. 2. Tried to reproduce it in the browser. Suddenly, the Key preview stuck at one point. Closed the browser view. Restarted it. And tried to reproduce the same issue. Still, no luck.

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

@mcdurdin @darcywong00 Today, I was able to see the issue (ie., sticky key preview) in the Android 11 / API 30 emulator. Here, What I did is: 1. I used the Keyman Keyboard as the System Keyboard and opened Chrome browser. 2. Tried to reproduce it in the browser. Suddenly, the Key preview stuck at one point. Closed the browser view. Restarted it. And tried to reproduce the same issue. Still, no luck.

This is interesting because I experience no problem in the Chrome browser at all. The sticking issue is never a problem there, nor is it a problem for any characters other than those either side of the spacebar.

A friend who uses an iPhone says it works fine for him and he does not have this problem.

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

I tried to repeat the key strokes from @Runeboard 's video. I see at 0:48, he hits the shift button but the layer remains on default. Then typing the ᛭ at 0:50 gets stuck.

But so far I haven't been able reproduce hitting the shift button and not have the layer change...

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

I tried to repeat the key strokes from @Runeboard 's video. I see at 0:48, he hits the shift button but the layer remains on default. Then typing the ᛭ at 0:50 gets stuck.

But so far I haven't been able reproduce hitting the shift button and not have the layer change...

That bug has already been fixed in version 1.1.

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

@Runeboard - are you still experiencing this issue with Keyman for Android 16.0?

Runeboard commented 1 year ago

@Runeboard - are you still experiencing this issue with Keyman for Android 16.0?

Yes, but not if I tap the key very quickly. It still occurs if I tap it at normal speed though.

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

@Runeboard - are you still experiencing this issue with Keyman for Android 16.0?

Yes, but not if I tap the key very quickly. It still occurs if I tap it at normal speed though.

Can you post another current video of the issue? We're still having difficulty in reproducing the issue.

darcywong00 commented 1 year ago

Will defer to future (Waiting on external) until @Runeboard can update with a current video for us to reproduce the issue

Runeboard commented 11 months ago

As it's only happening in the Keyman app itself, but not when the keyboard is used in other apps, I no longer consider it a problem worth addressing. Thanks for caring about it but as an easy workaround solution exists anyway, I think it matters so little that it may as well be ignored.

ermshiperete commented 11 months ago

This can also happen with apps build by SAB or RAB because they use the keyboard in the same way. But so far we haven't heard any other reports of this bug and we can't reproduce it, so we leave it closed.