Closed rajdip-b closed 2 months ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Error Handling The controller methods don't include explicit error handling. Consider adding try-catch blocks or error handling middleware to manage potential API errors gracefully. Code Duplication The API endpoint construction is repeated in each method. Consider extracting this logic into a separate method to improve maintainability. Test Data Management The test suite creates and deletes test data in beforeAll/afterAll hooks. Consider using a separate test database or mocking the API calls to avoid potential side effects. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Maintainability |
โ Correct the typo in the type name for consistency___Suggestion Impact:The typo in the type name CheckWOrkspaceRoleExistsRequest was corrected to CheckWorkspaceRoleExistsRequest. code diff: ```diff - CheckWOrkspaceRoleExistsRequest + CheckWorkspaceRoleExistsRequest } from '@api-client/types/workspace-role.types' export default class WorkspaceRoleController { @@ -62,7 +63,7 @@ } async checkWorkspaceRoleExists( - request: CheckWOrkspaceRoleExistsRequest, + request: CheckWorkspaceRoleExistsRequest, ```checkWorkspaceRoleExists method has a typo in the type name CheckWOrkspaceRoleExistsRequest . This should be corrected to maintain consistency and avoid potential issues.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-role.ts [64-67]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/430/files#diff-7bed7d7dd377ccffbc718e4a4195a7f10edbb5bcab01927160935892168408bfR64-R67) ```diff async checkWorkspaceRoleExists( - request: CheckWOrkspaceRoleExistsRequest, + request: CheckWorkspaceRoleExistsRequest, headers?: Record Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Correcting the typo in the type name is crucial for consistency and avoiding potential bugs, making this a high-priority fix. | 9 |
Best practice |
โ Use a more robust method for constructing URLs with query parameters___ **ThegetWorkspaceRolesOfWorkspace method constructs the URL manually, which can be error-prone. Consider using a URL builder library or a helper function to construct the URL with query parameters more safely and efficiently.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-role.ts [92-98]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/430/files#diff-7bed7d7dd377ccffbc718e4a4195a7f10edbb5bcab01927160935892168408bfR92-R98) ```diff -let url = `/api/workspace-role/${request.workspaceSlug}/all?` -request.page && (url += `page=${request.page}&`) -request.limit && (url += `limit=${request.limit}&`) -request.sort && (url += `sort=${request.sort}&`) -request.order && (url += `order=${request.order}&`) -request.search && (url += `search=${request.search}&`) +const queryParams = new URLSearchParams({ + ...(request.page && { page: request.page.toString() }), + ...(request.limit && { limit: request.limit.toString() }), + ...(request.sort && { sort: request.sort }), + ...(request.order && { order: request.order }), + ...(request.search && { search: request.search }), +}); +const url = `/api/workspace-role/${request.workspaceSlug}/all?${queryParams}`; const response = await this.apiClient.get(url, headers) ``` `[Suggestion has been applied]` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using a URL builder library or helper function reduces the risk of errors in URL construction, improving code reliability and readability. This is a significant improvement in best practices. | 8 |
โ Improve null value handling in test suite___Suggestion Impact:The non-null assertion was removed from the workspaceSlug assignment, which aligns with the suggestion to handle potential null values more robustly. code diff: ```diff - workspaceSlug: workspaceSlug!, + workspaceSlug, ```! ) frequently. Consider using a more robust approach to handle potential null values, such as conditional checks or throwing meaningful errors if the values are unexpectedly null.** [packages/api-client/tests/workspace-role.spec.ts [38-45]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/430/files#diff-50ef242eeac8e109aa4db36b3bb908a4d5c5c12ae9e1c95585ae5f37efa4d06dR38-R45) ```diff +if (!workspaceSlug) { + throw new Error('Workspace slug is null or undefined'); +} const createWorkspaceRoleRequest: CreateWorkspaceRoleRequest = { - workspaceSlug: workspaceSlug!, + workspaceSlug: workspaceSlug, name: 'Developer', description: 'Role for developers', colorCode: '#FF0000', authorities: ['READ_WORKSPACE', 'READ_PROJECT'], projectSlugs: [] } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion enhances the robustness of the test suite by handling potential null values more explicitly, which is a good practice but not critical for the test's functionality. | 6 | |
Error handling |
Implement more specific error handling for API responses___ **Consider using a more specific error handling mechanism instead of relying on thegeneric parseResponse function. This could involve creating custom error classes for different types of API errors and handling them explicitly in the controller methods.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-role.ts [36]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/430/files#diff-7bed7d7dd377ccffbc718e4a4195a7f10edbb5bcab01927160935892168408bfR36-R36) ```diff -return await parseResponse Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves error handling by introducing specific error classes, which enhances code robustness and maintainability. However, it is not critical for functionality, hence a moderate score. | 7 |
:tada: This PR is included in version 2.5.0 :tada:
The release is available on GitHub release
Your semantic-release bot :package::rocket:
User description
Description
Fixes #355
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
WorkspaceRoleController
to manage workspace roles, including methods for creating, updating, deleting, and fetching roles.WorkspaceRoleController
, covering all CRUD operations and role existence checks.Changes walkthrough ๐
workspace-role.ts
Implement Workspace Role Controller with CRUD operations
packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-role.ts
WorkspaceRoleController
class for managing workspace roles.workspace roles.
workspace-role.types.d.ts
Define Types for Workspace Role Operations
packages/api-client/src/types/workspace-role.types.d.ts
roles.
workspace-role.spec.ts
Add Tests for Workspace Role Controller
packages/api-client/tests/workspace-role.spec.ts
WorkspaceRoleController
methods.jest.config.ts
Update Jest Configuration for Workspace Role Tests
packages/api-client/jest.config.ts - Updated test match pattern to focus on workspace role tests.