Closed unamdev0 closed 2 weeks ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Search Functionality The search functionality has been modified to only search in the 'name' field, removing the ability to search in the 'description' field. This might impact existing search behavior. Data Validation The `icon` field is added as an optional string without any specific validation. Consider adding validation for allowed icon formats or characters. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Add a maximum length constraint to the icon field in the database schema___ **Consider adding a maximum length constraint to theicon field to prevent excessively long icon strings and ensure consistent data storage.** [apps/api/src/prisma/schema.prisma [457]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/435/files#diff-24191263d57c55d02e0cdf394de15225b628d1da20bd826b1541b59b6b02adb4R457-R457) ```diff -icon String? +icon String? @db.VarChar(255) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding a length constraint ensures data consistency and prevents potential issues with excessively long strings, which is a good practice for database schema design. | 8 |
Use a more descriptive icon in workspace creation tests___ **Consider using a more descriptive icon in the test case to better represent areal-world scenario and improve test readability.** [apps/api/src/workspace/workspace.e2e.spec.ts [195]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/435/files#diff-7a691e843fbdae323f1cabe7a12508154fbc917a1a738e5a67a1747fb7c581eaR195-R195) ```diff -icon: "๐ค" +icon: "๐ข" // Office building icon to represent a workspace ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: While using a more descriptive icon can improve test readability, it is a minor improvement and does not significantly impact the functionality or correctness of the tests. | 5 | |
Maintainability |
Use a constant for repeated icon values in tests___ **Consider using a constant for the repeated icon value "๐ค" to improve maintainabilityand consistency across tests.** [apps/api/src/event/event.e2e.spec.ts [102]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/435/files#diff-e3b2a34abdd21ac689f251a13fc249d534413e3c14ed8a6ae7374021b1663fe2R102-R102) ```diff +const WORKSPACE_ICON = "๐ค"; const workspace = await workspaceService.createWorkspace(user, { name: 'My workspace', - icon: "๐ค" + icon: WORKSPACE_ICON }) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using a constant for repeated values improves maintainability and consistency, making it easier to update the icon value across multiple tests if needed. | 7 |
Performance |
Use a more specific search condition for workspace names___ **Consider using a more specific search condition for the workspace name, such as'startsWith' instead of 'contains', to potentially improve search performance and accuracy.** [apps/api/src/workspace/service/workspace.service.ts [214-216]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/435/files#diff-a92613f23cf2834d52eaedb87c4e8c460d48b6fca8df4ccc968b2a8af19a9c3fR214-R216) ```diff name: { - contains: search + startsWith: search } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using 'startsWith' instead of 'contains' can improve search performance and accuracy, but it may limit the flexibility of search functionality. | 6 |
Hey bro, I think you misunderstood the issue. We didn't want to remove the description field. We just wanted to have an additional icon
field.
oh, it was mentioned by @kriptonian1 in issue's description, @kriptonian1 can you confirm if you meant to remove it from the frontend
Oh right, yes, my bad.
User description
Description
Added icon and removed description field from workspace
Fixes #229
Screenshots of relevant screens
Additional changes Required
Sample response for fetching all workspace of a user
Request Body for creating a new Workspace
PR Type
enhancement, tests
Description
description
field with anicon
field in the workspace model, affecting creation and update operations.description
and addition oficon
.description
toicon
.icon
field.Changes walkthrough ๐
workspace.ts
Replace description with icon in workspace creation
apps/api/src/common/workspace.ts - Replaced `description` field with `icon` in workspace creation.
create.workspace.ts
Update DTO to include icon instead of description
apps/api/src/workspace/dto/create.workspace/create.workspace.ts - Changed optional field from `description` to `icon` in DTO.
workspace.service.ts
Update workspace service to use icon instead of description
apps/api/src/workspace/service/workspace.service.ts
description
withicon
in workspace service logic.description
.migration.sql
Database migration to replace description with icon
apps/api/src/prisma/migrations/20240915122629_add_icon_remove_description_from_workspace/migration.sql
description
column and addedicon
column inWorkspace
table.schema.prisma
Update Prisma schema for workspace icon
apps/api/src/prisma/schema.prisma
description
field and addedicon
field inWorkspace
model.event.e2e.spec.ts
Update tests to reflect workspace icon change
apps/api/src/event/event.e2e.spec.ts
icon
instead ofdescription
for workspace.workspace-membership.e2e.spec.ts
Modify tests for workspace icon update
apps/api/src/workspace-membership/workspace-membership.e2e.spec.ts
icon
instead ofdescription
for workspace.workspace.e2e.spec.ts
Update workspace tests for icon field
apps/api/src/workspace/workspace.e2e.spec.ts - Updated workspace tests to use `icon` instead of `description`.