Closed Nil2000 closed 2 months ago
β±οΈ Estimated effort to review: 3 π΅π΅π΅βͺβͺ |
π§ͺ PR contains tests |
π No security concerns identified |
β‘ Key issues to review Error Handling The controller methods don't include explicit error handling. Consider adding try-catch blocks or error handling middleware to manage potential API errors gracefully. Test Coverage While the tests cover the basic functionality, they lack assertions for specific response properties and error scenarios. Consider adding more detailed assertions and error case tests. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Input validation |
Add input validation for request parameters before making API calls___ **Consider implementing input validation for the request parameters before making APIcalls. This can help prevent unnecessary API calls with invalid data and provide better error messages to the client.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-membership.ts [35-44]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/452/files#diff-9cefca6b94d518b82ce149083ebd84ef032fe360df595f1cba6d91fb85ddbc62R35-R44) ```diff async transferOwnership( request: TransferOwnershipRequest, headers?: Record Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Implementing input validation is crucial for preventing invalid data from being sent to the API, which can reduce unnecessary API calls and improve error messaging. This is a significant improvement in terms of data integrity and user experience. | 9 |
Error handling |
Implement specific error handling for API requests to provide more detailed error information___ **Consider using a more specific error handling mechanism for API requests. Instead ofrelying on the generic error handling provided by the APIClient, you could wrap each API call in a try-catch block to handle specific error cases and provide more detailed error information to the caller.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-membership.ts [39-44]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/452/files#diff-9cefca6b94d518b82ce149083ebd84ef032fe360df595f1cba6d91fb85ddbc62R39-R44) ```diff -const response = await this.apiClient.put( - `/api/workspace-membership/${request.workspaceSlug}/transfer-ownership/${request.userEmail}`, - request, - headers -) -return await parseResponse Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion enhances error handling by providing more specific error information, which can improve debugging and user feedback. It addresses a significant aspect of robustness in API interactions. | 8 |
Testing |
Add negative test cases to ensure proper error handling___ **Consider adding negative test cases to ensure the controller handles error scenarioscorrectly. This could include tests for invalid inputs, network errors, or API errors.** [packages/api-client/tests/workspace-membership.spec.ts [33-43]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/452/files#diff-51217021dfbc8a7925c518b52884af0daf5c34df7757913e229aca1dd4dbd3caR33-R43) ```diff it('should transfer ownership', async () => { const request = { workspaceSlug: workspaceSlug!, userEmail: userEmail } const response = await workspaceMembershipController.transferOwnership( request, { 'x-e2e-user-email': userEmail } ) expect(response).toBeTruthy() }) +it('should handle invalid input when transferring ownership', async () => { + const invalidRequest = { workspaceSlug: '', userEmail: '' } + await expect(workspaceMembershipController.transferOwnership(invalidRequest, { + 'x-e2e-user-email': userEmail + })).rejects.toThrow('Invalid request') +}) + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding negative test cases is important for ensuring that the application handles error scenarios correctly, which is crucial for maintaining robustness and reliability in production environments. | 8 |
Performance |
Implement a rate limiting mechanism to prevent API abuse___ **Consider implementing a rate limiting mechanism to prevent abuse of the API. Thiscould be done by adding a delay between consecutive API calls or by tracking the number of calls made within a certain time frame.** [packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-membership.ts [28-33]](https://github.com/keyshade-xyz/keyshade/pull/452/files#diff-9cefca6b94d518b82ce149083ebd84ef032fe360df595f1cba6d91fb85ddbc62R28-R33) ```diff export default class WorkspaceMembershipController { private apiClient: APIClient + private lastCallTime: number = 0 + private readonly minTimeBetweenCalls: number = 1000 // 1 second constructor(private readonly backendUrl: string) { this.apiClient = new APIClient(this.backendUrl) } + private async rateLimit() { + const now = Date.now() + const timeSinceLastCall = now - this.lastCallTime + if (timeSinceLastCall < this.minTimeBetweenCalls) { + await new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, this.minTimeBetweenCalls - timeSinceLastCall)) + } + this.lastCallTime = Date.now() + } + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: While rate limiting is important for preventing API abuse, the suggestion is more of a performance optimization rather than a critical fix. It is beneficial but not immediately necessary for the functionality. | 7 |
π‘ Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
@rajdip-b Let me know if it's fine or require any changes
:tada: This PR is included in version 2.6.0 :tada:
The release is available on GitHub release
Your semantic-release bot :package::rocket:
User description
Description
Created controller for Workspace Membership module
Fixes #446
Dependencies
Mention any dependencies/packages used
Future Improvements
Mention any improvements to be done in future related to any file/feature
Mentions
Mention and tag the people
Screenshots of relevant screens
Add screenshots of relevant screens
Developer's checklist
If changes are made in the code:
Documentation Update
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
WorkspaceMembershipController
to manage workspace memberships, including methods for transferring ownership, inviting/removing users, updating roles, and handling invitations.Authority
enum.WorkspaceMembershipController
.WorkspaceMembershipController
to ensure correct functionality of all methods.Changes walkthrough π
workspace-membership.ts
Implement Workspace Membership Controller with API Methods
packages/api-client/src/controllers/workspace-membership.ts
WorkspaceMembershipController
class with methods for managingworkspace memberships.
users, updating roles, and handling invitations.
index.ts
Export Workspace Membership Controller in API Client
packages/api-client/src/index.ts - Imported and exported `WorkspaceMembershipController`.
workspace-membership.types.d.ts
Define Types for Workspace Membership Operations
packages/api-client/src/types/workspace-membership.types.d.ts
Authority
enum for role permissions.workspace-membership.spec.ts
Add Tests for Workspace Membership Controller
packages/api-client/tests/workspace-membership.spec.ts
WorkspaceMembershipController
methods.updates.