search

kleros / court

The Kleros court user interface.
https://court.kleros.io
MIT License
21 stars 18 forks source link

Add the losing side appeal duration on the dispute periods timeline #301

Open jaybuidl opened 2 years ago

jaybuidl commented 2 years ago

Issue

Some users reported that the UX is confusing for the losing side of a dispute who may want to appeal. The timeline shows the overall appeal duration period, which is most relevant to the winning side, but rather misleading for the losing side. image

Note

The screen below does show the correct information for both sides, but the point is that the image above remains misleading. image

Possible solution

The easiest is to add a mention "(for the winning side)" next to Appeal here, and possibly add another label for relevant to the losing side (either by giving the losing side appeal duration, or either by redirecting them to the correct info).

greenlucid commented 1 year ago

Where did you take the 1st screenshot? That's https://github.com/kleros/dispute-resolver , not Court, right?

The issue here with this is that the Court is agnostic to how the appeal system of the Arbitrable works. The Arbitrable might allow sniping appeals, or not appeals at all, or use other exotic systems. In practice, this has never been the case, as all Arbitrables respect the 1/2 appeal period for loser side. So it could be added to the interface

I'd close this as wontfix since solving this is in scope for kleros-v2, and there's no elegant solution to the problem