search

kmcgill88 / admob_flutter

Admob Flutter plugin that shows banner ads using native platform views.
https://pub.dartlang.org/packages/admob_flutter
ISC License
434 stars 151 forks source link

Discouraged banner implementation #194

Open flutterkd opened 4 years ago

flutterkd commented 4 years ago

https://support.google.com/admob/answer/6275345?hl=en&ref_topic=2936214

In this link they said banner ad should not move as per user scroll Then why this package ❓❓❓❓

kmcgill88 commented 4 years ago

I have seen this documentation. The demo app needs to be updated. Nothing is stopping you from using the banner ad in other ways. I generally keep the banner fixed at the top or bottom of my apps.

kmcgill88 commented 4 years ago

If anyone has capacity to update the demo app please PR. The banner needs to be fixed instead of in a list.

kmcgill88 commented 4 years ago

Adding the direct quote from admob docs banner ads should not move as a user scrolls, as users may try to click on the menu but end up clicking on the ad accidentally instead. This specific implementation is against policy and we reserve the right to disable ad serving to your app.

I'm in the process of refactoring the demo app.

jagomf commented 4 years ago

Also, banner ads should not move as a user scrolls, as users may try to click on the menu but end up clicking on the ad accidentally instead

I understand that ads should not move on their own or in a different pace than the scroll itself, so that users do not click accidentally. It is not possible to click accidentally if the banners are "fixed" in a list, each one in a position, so I don't see any problem with the implementation of this package.

@kmcgill88 is AdmobBanner implementation expected to change? I currently have banners along a list and currently it works fine (despite important performance issues).

mingosnunes commented 3 years ago

If we can use this package as a native ad we can put it on the scroll view.

Please put it on the roadmap.

Many thanks.

hicnar commented 3 years ago

Technically speaking what you call a banner is in fact a native ad and this can be placed in a scrollable content container as long as it is clearly separated from the content itself.