search

knowledge-graphs-tutorial / examples

Examples from knowledge graphs tutorial paper
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
72 stars 7 forks source link

figure9c.ttl: Can :singletonPropertyOf be replaced with something more standard? #3

Open lschmelzeisen opened 3 years ago

lschmelzeisen commented 3 years ago

Figure 9 of the paper (2.4.2) depicts an example of representing temporal context using singleton properties:

singleton-properties

The example currently encodes this in RDF using :singletonPropertyOf:

https://github.com/knowledge-graphs-tutorial/examples/blob/37cc7fda85450d9caec87a946acac98d46e74b5b/Section2/2_4_2_Reification/figure9c.ttl#L10

This property type seems non-standard. Is there anything available in some standard with which we could replace this?

aidhog commented 3 years ago

If I recall correctly, the original paper uses rdf:singletonPropertyOf as they were proposing it as an extension of the RDF standard, but it's not actually defined there so I don't think it's a good idea to use this.

Searching in LOV doesn't reveal any other standard options: https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov/terms?q=singleton+property

lschmelzeisen commented 3 years ago

So would it be fair to say that there currently is no established standard on how to represent this example? If yes, we should note this in the file.

Also, if that is the case, we maybe potentially possibly could have cut it from the paper ;)