search

ksh93 / ksh

ksh 93u+m: KornShell lives! | Latest release: https://github.com/ksh93/ksh/releases
Eclipse Public License 2.0
192 stars 32 forks source link

History numbers are set to large number if fc is called in particular way. #744

Open kaesluder opened 7 months ago

kaesluder commented 7 months ago

I've been experimenting with implementing fzf history search, and found the following error if fc is called with an invalid argument. I've put in as close as I can get to a minimal example below. Calling fc with the output of $(history $HISTSIZE | fzf | cut -f1) renumbers history relative to a very large number. History resets if ksh is exited, sometimes clearing the history file, although I've not been able to reliably trigger tha.

Getting fzf running for this case is entirely optional. I'm more concerned about potential history and/or memory corruption.

20 ~ $ fc $(history $HISTSIZE | fzf | cut -f1)
ksh: hist: 50000-20: invalid range

...

1454470982 ~ $ echo $PS1
! ${RELATIVE_PWD}$(getBranch) $ $(__zoxide_hook)
1454470983 ~ $ history
1454470968      source ~/fzfc.ksh
1454470969      source ~/fzfc.ksh
1454470970      ls
1454470971      history 500
1454470972      exit
1454470973      history

Oops, forgot version sh (AT&T Research) 93u+m/1.0.8 2024-01-01

hlangeveld commented 7 months ago

I thought ksh93 updated history files real time. The problem starts when you have multiple sessions open, for which I used a hack to incorporate the name of my current tty into the history file (which I would keep in a ~/.hist directory). Tricky bit was that ksh93 would require a restart to change the history file on startup.

What is the value of the HISTFILE you use? And do you have any other shells using that same file? Do they save in real time or on exit?

kaesluder commented 7 months ago

History file is set to $HOME/.kshrc_history

Aaaaand, now I can't reproduce the problem, although I did earlier today for u+m and u. I seem to remember having the same weirdness using ksh2020.

I tested it originally with only one ksh running. I'm running two interactive shells now and it looks like they're sharing history (and the line number on the prompt) with no issues. But as I said, I can't seem to break it following the same steps now.

kaesluder commented 3 months ago

I have not seen this happen since updating on OpenSUSE. Ticket can be closed.