kubecost / features-bugs

A public repository for filing of Kubecost feature requests and bugs. Please read the issue guidelines before filing an issue here.
0 stars 0 forks source link

Alerts with custom content added through templates #91

Closed shauryaBlue closed 3 weeks ago

shauryaBlue commented 1 year ago

What problem are you trying to solve? We would like to add more details with the alerts generated through Kubecost. Eg. Attaching links to the kubecost dashboard / Reports attached to the emails / Details on what action is to be taken

Describe the solution you'd like Feature for adding messages with dynamic content through HTLM / text on the alerts Eg. i. https://plugins.jenkins.io/email-ext/#plugin-content-groovy-script-content-templates ii. https://argocd-notifications.readthedocs.io/en/stable/services/email/#template

Describe alternatives you've considered Currently, we generate custom alerts using a separate automation which uses Kubecost APIs & runs daily with a cron schedule

How would users interact with this feature? Alert notification templates can be added to the helm charts

priyadharsanR commented 1 year ago

Same issue i also facing

thomasvn commented 1 year ago

@shauryaBlue Thanks for the feature request! Could you share how you've currently configured your alerting?

@kwombach12 Could you provide some input here when you return?

shauryaBlue commented 1 year ago

Sure @thomasvn

Alerts are currently added per namespace to the helm chart

     alertConfigs:
        globalAlertEmails:
        - <>
        alerts: 
        - type: efficiency
          efficiencyThreshold: 0.6
          spendThreshold: 10
          window: 7d
          aggregation: namespace
          ownerContact:
          - <>

However, the alert generated by this does not provide sufficient details as to what action a namespace owner should take. We would like to attach custom data ( mainly kubecost container request recommendations ) along with the alert.

Current alert :

Efficiency for namespace <> (14%) dropped below the allowed threshold of 30%. Total Spend during Efficiency Alert: 58

Required alert example :

[Alert] Efficiency for namespace <> (14%) dropped below the allowed threshold of 30%. Please review kubecost recommendations for setting requests here : <>

Total Spend during Efficiency Alert: 58 This has increased by <>% in the past 2 weeks

The customisation of these messages would be great, as we could point application teams to required resources they can use

kwombach12 commented 1 year ago

@shauryaBlue Would it be sufficient to link users back to Kuebcost savings when a drop in efficiency is detected? Are there other types of customizations you're looking for?

shauryaBlue commented 1 year ago

Sure, that would be great @kwombach12

Ideally however - customisations with templatization would be even better. This would allow admins to link other tools / reports along with the alerts.

kwombach12 commented 1 year ago

@shauryaBlue My concern about allowing for customization in the alerts is that could lead to security vulnerabilities. @teevans Would you agree with that?

chipzoller commented 3 weeks ago

Hello, in an effort to consolidate our bug and feature request tracking, we are deprecating using GitHub to track tickets. If this issue is still outstanding and you have not done so already, please raise a request at https://support.kubecost.com/.