Does not work with '-' or '/' in named route

[jensb]

Given this route:

ActionDispatch::Routing::SEPARATORS << "-" unless ActionDispatch::Routing::SEPARATORS.include?("-")
match '/product-:name-:id' => 'products#show'

i18n_routing will throw an error

compile error /Library/Ruby/Gems/1.8/gems/actionpack-3.0.4/lib/action_dispatch/routing/route_set.rb:161: syntax error, unexpected '-', expecting '\n' or ';' 

I suspect this is because I am using different parameter separators than the default '/' and '.' (for SEO optimization).

How would I be able use this plugin in combination with such routes?

Thanks!

[jensb]

I found the problem: If you omit ":as => :something", i18n_routing will try to use the path as a function name. Which usually fails, because the path contains characters not allowed in function names, like '/', ':', '-', etc.

If I add unique :as parameters to all my routes, then it seems to work.

[kwi]

Hmm, I think you can't do it in rails itself apparently, so it will not be possible with i18n_routing too :/ Btw, no sure /products-name is better than /products/name in term of SEO (the last one give you a nice categorization) Also for the :name-:id, use the to_param method on your product object to achieve this trick.

You are welcome :)

2011/10/4 jensb < reply@reply.github.com>

Given this route:

ActionDispatch::Routing::SEPARATORS << "-" unless ActionDispatch::Routing::SEPARATORS.include?("-") match '/product-:name-:id' => 'products#show'

i18n_routing will throw an error

compile error /Library/Ruby/Gems/1.8/gems/actionpack-3.0.4/lib/action_dispatch/routing/route_set.rb:161: syntax error, unexpected '-', expecting '\n' or ';'

I suspect this is because I am using different parameter separators than the default '/' and '.' (for SEO optimization).

How would I be able use this plugin in combination with such routes?

Thanks!

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/kwi/i18n_routing/issues/25

[jensb]

The above example was just an example. :) For SEO purposes we don't use '/' because words after '/' will be interpreted as having a lower priority / hierarchy by search engines, which is not the case here (all words in the URL have the same priority).

# routes.rb
match '/product-:name-:id' => 'products#show', :as => :product_show

Your plugin works if I add ":as => ..." names to each route (which I don't have to do otherwise); and use the routes themselves in the YML file as lookup keys, instead of the route names, as in

# config/locales/de.yml
de:
  named_routes_path:
    '/product-:name-:id': '/produkt-:name-:id'

For easier route maintenance, I would have preferred something like

# config/locales/de.yml
de:
  named_routes_path:
    product_show: '/produkt-:name-:id'

because that would allow updating of the route in routes.rb without having to change all keys in the translations. Is it possible to add this feature?

Also, I would like to use ERB blocks in the locales file (because some of my routes in routes.rb are also created within loops). Would it be possible to add this feature?