search

kytos-ng / kytos

Kytos SDN Platform. Kytos is designed to be easy to install, use, develop and share Network Apps (NApps).
https://kytos-ng.github.io/
MIT License
2 stars 7 forks source link

User not notified when creating a new EVC using a disabled interface #440

Open RenataFrez opened 5 months ago

RenataFrez commented 5 months ago

While adding a new EVC using one or more endpoints that are disabled on Kytos, the Web Interface creates the EVC without any warning, just the usual message showing the EVC was created.

We can see the EVC as "Not Active" by checking the Web Interface.

Checking the Kytos logs, we can see that the EVC wasn't deployed:

2024-01-24 14:26:11,081 - WARNING [kytos.napps.kytos/mef_eline] [evc.py:740:deploy_to_path] (Thread-442602) EVC(fb4b6602ea7a40, Vlan_699_Loop_test_temp) was not deployed. No available path was found.

A user/admin can be led to believe there is something wrong with the network, but it is just a matter of enabling the interface or not using it.

Also, even if the interface is later enabled, the EVC will work only after a redeploy.

viniarck commented 5 months ago

Hi @RenataFrez, thanks for bringing this up. Yes, that's the currently behavior.

We can provide stronger validation guarantees if it's not desirable to even allow the EVC to be created if an UNI is disabled. Sometime ago, a related discussion was started on issue https://github.com/kytos-ng/mef_eline/issues/332, please check it out.

I believe the first step is indeed to map the rest of the use cases / scenarios where network operators do not want to allow an EVC creation then it can get implemented, also let us know the priority of this issue and we can eventually prioritize it.

viniarck commented 4 months ago

I'll set this on 2024.1 to keep on our radar to be discussed in the next planning