search

lab-carpentry / blueprint-resourcesharing

Template resource sharing plans for grant applications
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
3 stars 3 forks source link

Add README and initial resource sharing plan #1

Closed dhimmel closed 7 years ago

dhimmel commented 7 years ago

This resource sharing plan is based on one @cgreene and I wrote for a grant that @cgreene and @bdsullivan are submitting to the NIH.

The main goal is to ensure that project outputs are openly licensed.

Who owns academic data/content is complicated, so these resource sharing plans should ensure open licensing regardless of owner.

Another goal is to prevent license incompatibilities down the road. Hence, the creators and investigators are provided the ability to release content as CC0.

Comments please!

dhimmel commented 7 years ago

@jakevdp, I saw your tweet on git for prose.

Does the formatting of prose in this PR look good to you? Any suggestions to make maintaining prose easier?

jakevdp commented 7 years ago

Does the formatting of prose in this PR look good to you?

Looks pretty good!

cgreene commented 7 years ago

To go along with @ethanwhite's comment, you may want to specify that this is for NIH grants (where it does not count towards page limits). Maybe prefix resource-sharing-plan.md with nih so you have nih-resource-sharing-plan.md. Then as people work this into other grants, they may be willing to commit back ones that fit other funder requirements.

strasser commented 7 years ago

I like it! There isn't as much detail as I would like to see in a data sharing plan from grantees, so you might also add that this might not be sufficient for all funders. Perhaps point to DCC or DMPTool as resource. Might ask Stephanie Simms from CDL/DMPtool to look? Can connect if you'd like

dhimmel commented 7 years ago

you may want to specify that this is for NIH grants (where it does not count towards page limits).

@cgreene, done

My one major suggestion is to think about where exactly this will end up for most funders and whether that means it might be worthwhile trying to shorten it.

@ethanwhite I changed the repository to be a collection of many examples. This initial example is for the NIH, where the resource sharing plan doesn't count as part of the grant size limit. Hopefully, we can get contributions with plans for alternative funders.

There isn't as much detail as I would like to see in a data sharing plan from grantees, so you might also add that this might not be sufficient for all funders.

@strasser, I added the following to the prologue of the example:

This plan largely focuses on ensuring the open licensing of project outputs. Carly Strasser — a Program Officer for the Data-Driven Discovery Initiative at the Gordon & Betty Moore Foundation — suggests adding more details regarding your specific data outputs and corresponding sharing plans. For inspiration, see the Digital Curation Centre guide or public Data Management Plans.

cgreene commented 7 years ago

@dhimmel : when you merge, can you either file a PR or an issue against the website repo? We'll want to edit https://github.com/lab-carpentry/lab-carpentry.github.io/blob/master/pages/blueprints.md to link to this resource.