Check if IANA references pointing to RFC 4210 must be updated to rfc4210bis

[HBrock]

IANA wrote: Should those references be replaced with references to this document (this is typical)? For IANA’s purposes, this could be covered by a line that says something like “All existing references to RFC 4210 at https://www.iana.org/assignments/smi-numbers/smi-numbers.xhtml and https://www.iana.org/assignments/core-parameters/core-parameters.xhtml should be replaced with references to this document,” or “All existing references [...] except for the following registrations:”

[HBrock]

RFC XXXX is new RFC number of --> the assigned numerical RFC value for I-D.ietf-lamps-rfc4210bis RFC YYYY is new RFC number of --> the assigned numerical RFC value for I-D.ietf-lamps-rfc6712bis

https://www.iana.org/assignments/smi-numbers/smi-numbers.xhtml SMI Security for PKIX Module Identifier

• id-mod-cmp: keep RFC 2510
• id-mod-cmp2000: keep RFC 4210
• BTW: should RFC4211 be the reference for id-mod-crmf2005?
• id-mod-cmp2000-02: keep RFC 5912
• id-mod-cmp2021-88: keep RFC 9480
• id-mod-cmp2021-02: keep RFC 9480

SMI Security for PKIX Extended Key Purpose

• id-kp-cmKGA: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX

SMI Security for PKIX CMP Information Types

• id-it-caProtEncCert: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-signKeyPairTypes: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-encKeyPairTypes: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-preferredSymmAlg: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-caKeyUpdateInfo: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-currentCRL: RFC 2510 -> RFC XXX
• id-it-unsupportedOIDs: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-keyPairParamReq: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-keyPairParamRep: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-revPassphrase: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-implicitConfirm: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-confirmWaitTime: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-origPKIMessage: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-suppLangTags: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-caCerts: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-rootCaKeyUpdate: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-certReqTemplate: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-rootCaCert: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-certProfile: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-crlStatusList: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-it-crls: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX

SMI Security for PKIX CRMF Registration Controls

• id-regCtrl-altCertTemplate: RFC 4210 -> RFC XXXX
• id-regCtrl-algId: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX
• id-regCtrl-rsaKeyLen: RFC 9480 -> RFC XXXX

https://www.iana.org/assignments/core-parameters/core-parameters.xhtml CoAP Content-Formats

• application/pkixcmp: RFC 9482, RFC 4210 -> RFC 9482, RFC YYYY

[HBrock]

@russhousley may I ask for your advice? IANA asked me to specify which references shall be updated to the new RFC 4210bis and 6712bis. Above I provided a list. But I am uncertain if it is correct to update also references to the RFCs, where the OIDs were originally registered. For example I found OIDs with reference RFC 2510, even though the OID is still in use in RFC 4210. I had expected that this reference should have been updated to RFC 4210 back then.

[russhousley]

I did a very quick review. This looks correct to me.