the first slice is fetched in the main request, while all other slices are fetched in subrequests. Since you log only the main request (by default), the variable $upstream_cache_status returns cache status of the first slice, which is likely to be cached.
arut - https://trac.nginx.org/nginx/ticket/1200
This paints a rosy picture when logging via lancachenet/logstash and visualising in Kibana, showing hit ratios that are much better than they really are.
Simply enabling logging of subrequests with log_subrequest on would mean counting request bytes twice, once for the main request for e.g. 5MB, and then again for the 5x 1MB subrequests, throwing the graphs off another way.
Nginx doesn't have an equivalent to Apache's IS_SUBREQ variable, so some other way of differentiating main request log lines from subrequest lines is needed, potentially adding a header to one or other request and logging that, as discussed with @GotenXiao at UK LAN Techs hack weekend 2.0.
Once we can differentiate between log lines, in Kibana the graphs will need to be updated so that:
the "hit / miss" pie is drawn from subrequest log lines only
the "total bytes served" metric is drawn from main request log lines only
the "internet bandwidth saved" metric is drawn from subrequest log lines marked as a hit only
... and many of the other graphs too, to avoid counting bytes twice as described above.
Hello friends!
Using nginx's
slicemodule means that:This paints a rosy picture when logging via
lancachenet/logstashand visualising in Kibana, showing hit ratios that are much better than they really are.Simply enabling logging of subrequests with
log_subrequest onwould mean counting request bytes twice, once for the main request for e.g. 5MB, and then again for the 5x 1MB subrequests, throwing the graphs off another way.Nginx doesn't have an equivalent to Apache's
IS_SUBREQvariable, so some other way of differentiating main request log lines from subrequest lines is needed, potentially adding a header to one or other request and logging that, as discussed with @GotenXiao at UK LAN Techs hack weekend 2.0.Once we can differentiate between log lines, in Kibana the graphs will need to be updated so that:
... and many of the other graphs too, to avoid counting bytes twice as described above.
Thanks!