I'm working through the book sequentially and these are my comments on chapter 16. I've also made some direct edits to the text for more minor things and writing adjustments and issued a pull request.
something weird happening with the boxes in the is chapter e.g.,
Figure 16.1 weights column should be labelled?
"16.2.1 Within-study biases" - perhaps also mention bias arising from data-dependent analyses and refer back to the preregistration chapter
"Here is an example of one type of funnel plot (Mathur and VanderWeele 2020b) for a simulated meta-analysis of 100 studies with no publication bias:" -and "As implied by the “funnel” moniker, our plot looks a little like a funnel." - its not clear what figure is being referred to here, possibly a missing figure?
I'm working through the book sequentially and these are my comments on chapter 16. I've also made some direct edits to the text for more minor things and writing adjustments and issued a pull request.
something weird happening with the boxes in the is chapter e.g.,
Figure 16.1 weights column should be labelled?
"16.2.1 Within-study biases" - perhaps also mention bias arising from data-dependent analyses and refer back to the preregistration chapter
"Here is an example of one type of funnel plot (Mathur and VanderWeele 2020b) for a simulated meta-analysis of 100 studies with no publication bias:" -and "As implied by the “funnel” moniker, our plot looks a little like a funnel." - its not clear what figure is being referred to here, possibly a missing figure?
also missing a figure here?