Key not found, even with Juniper registration

[rabritta]

Hello. As seen in the attached print-screen, I am getting a "KeyError: key :ntur not found" error even after registering the function both in the model and in Juniper.

My registration looks like this:

nl_solver= optimizer_with_attributes(Ipopt.Optimizer, "print_level" => 0);
mip_solver = optimizer_with_attributes(Cbc.Optimizer, "logLevel" => 0);
optm = Model(optimizer_with_attributes(Juniper.Optimizer, "nl_solver"=>nl_solver, "mip_solver"=>mip_solver, 
        "allow_almost_solved_integral"=>true,
        "registered_functions"=>[Juniper.register(:ntur, 3, ntur, grad_ntur)]));

register(optm, :ntur, 3, ntur, grad_ntur);

I could not find this issue already posted. Although issue #118 is similar, it was solved by simply registering the function in Juniper, which is not my case. I realized that in #118 the stacktrace [2] is identical to mine:

expr_to_nodedata(::Expr, ::Array{ReverseDiffSparse.NodeData,1}, ::Array{Float64,1}, ::Int64, ::ReverseDiffSparse.UserOperatorRegistry) at conversion.jl:23". However, stacktrace [1] is "getindex at dict.jl:474 [inlined]" whereas mine is "getindex(::Dict{Symbol,Int64}, ::Symbol) at .\dict.jl:477

Any help is appreciated. Regards.

[Wikunia]

Thanks for the bug report. It seemed to slipped through testing. Hope it's fixed now. Would be awesome if you can test it with ] dev https://github.com/lanl-ansi/Juniper.jl and then in .julia/dev/Juniper.jl use git checkout bugfix-registered-functions which should show you v0.6.3 in ] status afterwards. If that works out I'll register the new version. And welcome to GitHub :)

Btw I've changed your issue slightly such that the code is more readable now. You can do this with "````" around your code block.

[rabritta]

Hey @Wikunia! Thanks for welcoming me and for showing me how to make the code more readable. I got the ] dev https://github.com/lanl-ansi/Juniper.jl part just fine but I couldn't figure the rest out. Apologies, I am pretty new to this stuff. I found the bugfix file and did the attempt below, but I believe I am messing things up.

[Wikunia]

No problem. I might have forgotten some parts: It's easiest to do in a shell but can be done in the REPL or in your notebook as well I believe. Can you try:

; cd C:/Users/Win10/.julia/Juniper/
; git checkout bugfix-registered-functions
] status

; brings you to shell mode. ] status should show Juniper v0.6.3 If that works you can just run your model and it should work fine.

[rabritta]

dev folder was missing, but I am still getting some errors

[Wikunia]

Can you use a shell outside Julia? I haven't used Windows for quite a while :smile: If you have git installed which I think you need when using Julia checkout should be working. Maybe you can run the commands in the PowerShell? change to the dev/Juniper folder and then run git checkout bugfix-registered-functions

[ccoffrin]

Did you try using this package manager command?

] add Juniper#bugfix-registered-functions

[rabritta]

It seems like using Jupyter notebook instead of Julia directly was a problem indeed. Anyway, @ccoffrin 's command did the trick, as seem in the image below. But I am still getting the "key :ntur not found" error. Stacktrace [1] is still [1] getindex(::Dict{Symbol,Int64}, ::Symbol) at .\dict.jl:477. Let me know if you want me to send you my code.

[Wikunia]

Thanks for testing it out. Yes sending the code would be much appreciated. If you don't want to make it public here feel free to send me an email o.kroeger@opensourc.es

[rabritta]

Won't be necessary. I just needed to restart the kernel after the previous steps. It is working fine now :) You guys are awesome

[ccoffrin]

Thanks for the report and glad we could quickly resolve the issue. Kudos to @Wikunia!