laomms / PidKeyTool

密钥检测工具. Tool for check Microsoft Product Key
270 stars 54 forks source link

PidKeyTool was tested and does not give proper results #13

Closed Quikfix73 closed 1 year ago

Quikfix73 commented 1 year ago

I tested this PidKeyTool and pretty much every key I've tested gives you a common Microsoft error code such as 0xC004C008 as one example. I've tried an online tool which does a way better job (that I personally tested) that is https://pidkeys.com and on this website if a key is NEW at the time of checking, this online website will come back with an error code "Error code: Online key".

Your PidKeyTool tool is not giving correct results because pretty much every key I have tested (new and used) come back with an error code such as 0xC004C008 so this PidKeyTool is unusable and I will stick with my online checker mentioned above and please note I only use this site https://pidkeys.com if a key is experiencing an issue.

Please note that I am very well aware that entering any key on a public website will most likely get harvested. (or the key will end up being used if the site checking website is using a Virtual Machine to activate the key you are checking to obtain an activation result)

Look at the key in screenshot (I have blocked most of the key for security reasons) came back as an 0xC004C008 error on your PidKeyTool program but this key was new at time of checking and at the time of checking this same key was given the result of a NEW key "Error code: Online key" on https://pidkeys.com so you need to fix your program so it gives correct error messages since I was able to activate this key hours later without any issues.

I have yet to obtain a NEW key error message which is "Error code: Online key" on any key that I tested and I have tested many keys using your PidKeyTool.

image

laomms commented 1 year ago

log

laomms commented 1 year ago

QQ图片20221227202446 The best way to determine whether the key is valid is to use Fiddler capture and analysis. The premise is that it must be tested on a PC that has not been activated. PidKeyTool is a tool written in this way.

Quikfix73 commented 1 year ago

image So basically what you have proven is exactly what I said. When you entered your test key 2QN4X-M2J4M-HFGR4-YXK7D-63BP6 (Windows 10 Pro Retail key good for 1 activation) in https://pidkeys.com this key was tested on their virtual server and it told you it was ONLINE (Online key error code message means the key was NEW at the time of testing) since their virtual server was able to activate it resulting in a "Error code: Online key". Then when you went to activate again by using Change Product Key in your Windows operating system after this key was tested on https://pidkeys.com it gave an error 0xC004C008 and this error means that the key is used more than the allowable limit.

I now tested this same key 2QN4X-M2J4M-HFGR4-YXK7D-63BP6 in https://pidkeys.com (refer to screenshot) and now it gives the same 0xC004C008 error as when you tried to activate it meaning the key was BURNED/USED immediately after you tested this key on https://pidkeys.com since this site uses a virtual server to activate keys in order to obtain Error code status results.

So I have CLEARLY PROVEN that there is no tool (program, app, or website) that exists that can give you the status of a Microsoft Windows key WITHOUT BURNING/USING 1 activation count from that key.

laomms commented 1 year ago
  1. Original 0xC004C008 remain max times is 5-20 times.
  2. Detect 0xC004C008 key is not possible to consume the remaining times. Unless the CID has been obtained.
  3. This key I ever tested at 2022/11/26 for the result is 0xC004C008. QQ图片20221228091008
  4. Yesterday some 008 keys maybe became online keys on this site , but today, some online keys may turn into 0xC004C008 on this site. QQ图片20221228101024

aaa