lay295 / TwitchDownloader

Twitch VOD/Clip Downloader - Chat Download/Render/Replay
MIT License
2.78k stars 261 forks source link

Audio Glitch #739

Closed andreazaimbri closed 1 year ago

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

Checklist

Edition

Windows GUI Application

Describe your issue here

Audio disturbances in the vod download.

lay295 commented 1 year ago

What's the VOD link? What program are you using to play back the file?

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

In VLC, and when I edit the video in Adobe Premiere I hear audio noise every 10 second.

lay295 commented 1 year ago

Cool, VOD link so I can try and reproduce the issue?

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

Can I attach the downloaded video?

ScrubN commented 1 year ago

Can I attach the downloaded video?

Yes you can

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

The file is too big, this is the vod link: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1844285066

lay295 commented 1 year ago

Kinda sound like the same as #352

But, I downloaded the whole VOD, and played via MPC-HC/VLC/Premier 2021 and audio sounds fine. I'm pretty sure these issues are usually decoding issues on the users end, not really a problem with the encoding itself.

I'd be interested if you'd be willing to upload your video file to like Google Drive, but I'm pretty sure it would play fine on my PC. But if I cannot reproduce the issue I'll probably end up closing this.

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1X2FU2Xpq_SbiwrjmuCsmY3FHEqOGmcCA/view?usp=sharing This is the downloaded vod.

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

This problem appears when i add the video on Adobe Premiere

ScrubN commented 1 year ago

I do not hear the audio disturbances in the google drive previewer, nor in VLC, MPV, or Vegas Pro 17. There is also no evidence of audio disturbances from 2 different spectrograms of the audio. image image

It is most likely that either your computer just needs a reboot or your audio drivers are bad.

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

If I download the Twitch vod with the video downloader extension, I don't notice any audio problems, while if I download with the Twitch Downloader the glitches are present. I attach a link of an edited video with premiere that contain the problem: https://youtu.be/bxWKXh_pjyc

andreazaimbri commented 1 year ago

The audio driver in my computer is updated, and I do not have other audio issues.

lay295 commented 1 year ago

There can be so many possible thing going wrong, but it's an issue isolated to just you.

When you uploaded it to Google Drive, Google was able to successfully decode/re-encode the file (since it has to for compression). On my computer in every program I try it decodes fine. Nobody else is reporting this, and this program has a good amount of users at this point where if there was widespread audio glitches when downloading any VOD it should be pretty well known.

Maybe something going wrong with premier? Maybe can toggle between hardware/software decoding on Premier? But again if I cannot reproduce it (which I cannot) I'm gonna close.

Skryah commented 12 months ago

Hi, I have this exact same issue in the same situation as him.
Same editing program (Adobe Premiere Pro), this issue only happens with footage that comes from TwitchDownloader. Tested multiple times with footage from different channels, and footage downloaded in other computers.
So I'm thinking the issue is not with your app but with Premiere and how it decodes audio, however, I'm out of ideas on how to fix it. I really like using your app and would hate if it continued this way, as it is a deal breaker.