LBRY New SDK Broken Comments

[juanpc2018]

Odysee comments are working ok in Odysee website.

LBRY for Linux, does Not load Comments. New SDK a few versions back broken the comment servers...

is Not Only Odysee coment server, its also Madiator comments server.

Broken. LBRY sdk has become incompatible with comments servers.

P.D. im Not banned because i log in to Odysee with same account as LBRY. Same IP. Same OS. Odysee works ok, exept the Video quality in this side of the Network, if using a VPN, Quality improves... its a Network bottleneck.

Anyway... When you Type a Banned word in Odysee, Odysee website warns you, that the comment is banned, very nice, instead YouTube shadow bans, makes you think the comment was posted. but only you can see your comment.

Odysee method is much better.

[keikari]

Comments seem to load fine here on v0.53.5-t109 when connected to Odysee comment server.

Does it show any errors for you?
Can you check if there are any errors in responses to comment related network calls in dev tools (Ctrl + Shift + i)

[juanpc2018]

madiator server v2 has Json error Network Status 502 https://comments.madiator.com/api/v2

since the SDK update.

---

odysee server 400 network erros.

https://clickstream.odysee.com/log/video/view data:undefined, sendRecsysEntry @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 onPlayerDispose @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n.onDispose @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 r.dispatcher.r.dispatcher @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 wr @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 trigger @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n.dispose @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 t.unstable_runWithPriority @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Gi @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 ul @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 gl @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 ws @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 t.unstable_runWithPriority @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Gi @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 ys @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 ls @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 t.unstable_runWithPriority @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Gi @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Zi @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Ki @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 N @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Zt @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2

fetch("https://clickstream.odysee.com/log/video/view", { "headers": { "content-type": "text/plain;charset=UTF-8" }, "referrer": "", "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"uuid\":\"ff19ab82-fb43-46ce-aee4-a603aeb9b105\",\"uid\":375630884,\"claimId\":\"ab250f8a0c82d58d4273b3a84790bcedf699d297\",\"pageLoadedAt\":1659670177924,\"recsysId\":\"lighthouse5\",\"recClaimIds\":[\"30fb36fc6d271bf22d8959ee612069e9992eaa64\",\"e5d5a28ade4abaf7ea6a6b0a8c2d1bda081b43ba\",\"5ba32a14dd685ddf410198c0a0e2e50252c55070\",\"5ec9ea68898469ad0392c9f5e0a0162db00b2eb3\",\"126525b5914d2b4d79cdf19db5f7bd37e67641af\",\"89f3e4b274a38c8ddb9e869a7f7b3f096c1e1ebc\",\"d40d119fc57911077ebf90cd69cbc52065325a96\",\"dc5c3197c852568d06a27f11049ba014f4ddc8c4\",\"f3f683209dd156e87d72b6ae09c1b03575dad885\",\"e8b474caefb306a0512b59625cc58be924175d41\",\"f861aa9d17f139ff3e4319806d7a1c3fa4a071ea\",\"6be337b124ffd020e36e3e98d88913a1114d7f09\",\"7eabe1522c60b87a5aa469d0d893ea1ff1af31a3\",\"8fe2885a793fdbefa6350677d267858d68f6aa03\",\"2889d5b50512b93f5bf07e71fe4632ec58bf645c\",\"eae1681233ba5b73d1ad299a3c465d5ce9d69c77\",\"f01ac70421a136a17ed5134d8fbb1eb0421e9680\",\"002494ba0c7148fc7c4293aae5972e35711b6274\",\"f8a28cc32adeb701e0da1d923cf7434e1b852132\"],\"recClickedVideoIdx\":[],\"events\":[{\"event\":1,\"offset\":0},{\"event\":3,\"offset\":0,\"arg\":1},{\"event\":3,\"offset\":0,\"arg\":1.25},{\"event\":0,\"offset\":0.006696},{\"event\":1,\"offset\":15.706865}]}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors", "credentials": "omit" });

fetch("https://clickstream.odysee.com/log/video/view", { "headers": { "content-type": "text/plain;charset=UTF-8" }, "referrer": "", "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"uuid\":\"ff19ab82-fb43-46ce-aee4-a603aeb9b105\",\"uid\":375630884,\"claimId\":\"ab250f8a0c82d58d4273b3a84790bcedf699d297\",\"pageLoadedAt\":1659670177924,\"recsysId\":\"lighthouse5\",\"recClaimIds\":[\"30fb36fc6d271bf22d8959ee612069e9992eaa64\",\"e5d5a28ade4abaf7ea6a6b0a8c2d1bda081b43ba\",\"5ba32a14dd685ddf410198c0a0e2e50252c55070\",\"5ec9ea68898469ad0392c9f5e0a0162db00b2eb3\",\"126525b5914d2b4d79cdf19db5f7bd37e67641af\",\"89f3e4b274a38c8ddb9e869a7f7b3f096c1e1ebc\",\"d40d119fc57911077ebf90cd69cbc52065325a96\",\"dc5c3197c852568d06a27f11049ba014f4ddc8c4\",\"f3f683209dd156e87d72b6ae09c1b03575dad885\",\"e8b474caefb306a0512b59625cc58be924175d41\",\"f861aa9d17f139ff3e4319806d7a1c3fa4a071ea\",\"6be337b124ffd020e36e3e98d88913a1114d7f09\",\"7eabe1522c60b87a5aa469d0d893ea1ff1af31a3\",\"8fe2885a793fdbefa6350677d267858d68f6aa03\",\"2889d5b50512b93f5bf07e71fe4632ec58bf645c\",\"eae1681233ba5b73d1ad299a3c465d5ce9d69c77\",\"f01ac70421a136a17ed5134d8fbb1eb0421e9680\",\"002494ba0c7148fc7c4293aae5972e35711b6274\",\"f8a28cc32adeb701e0da1d923cf7434e1b852132\"],\"recClickedVideoIdx\":[],\"events\":[{\"event\":1,\"offset\":0},{\"event\":3,\"offset\":0,\"arg\":1},{\"event\":3,\"offset\":0,\"arg\":1.25},{\"event\":0,\"offset\":0.006696},{\"event\":1,\"offset\":15.706865}]}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors" });

curl 'https://clickstream.odysee.com/log/video/view' \ -H 'Referer: ' \ -H 'User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) LBRY/0.53.5-t109 Chrome/94.0.4606.81 Electron/15.4.0 Safari/537.36' \ -H 'Content-Type: text/plain;charset=UTF-8' \ --data-raw '{"uuid":"ff19ab82-fb43-46ce-aee4-a603aeb9b105","uid":375630884,"claimId":"ab250f8a0c82d58d4273b3a84790bcedf699d297","pageLoadedAt":1659670177924,"recsysId":"lighthouse5","recClaimIds":["30fb36fc6d271bf22d8959ee612069e9992eaa64","e5d5a28ade4abaf7ea6a6b0a8c2d1bda081b43ba","5ba32a14dd685ddf410198c0a0e2e50252c55070","5ec9ea68898469ad0392c9f5e0a0162db00b2eb3","126525b5914d2b4d79cdf19db5f7bd37e67641af","89f3e4b274a38c8ddb9e869a7f7b3f096c1e1ebc","d40d119fc57911077ebf90cd69cbc52065325a96","dc5c3197c852568d06a27f11049ba014f4ddc8c4","f3f683209dd156e87d72b6ae09c1b03575dad885","e8b474caefb306a0512b59625cc58be924175d41","f861aa9d17f139ff3e4319806d7a1c3fa4a071ea","6be337b124ffd020e36e3e98d88913a1114d7f09","7eabe1522c60b87a5aa469d0d893ea1ff1af31a3","8fe2885a793fdbefa6350677d267858d68f6aa03","2889d5b50512b93f5bf07e71fe4632ec58bf645c","eae1681233ba5b73d1ad299a3c465d5ce9d69c77","f01ac70421a136a17ed5134d8fbb1eb0421e9680","002494ba0c7148fc7c4293aae5972e35711b6274","f8a28cc32adeb701e0da1d923cf7434e1b852132"],"recClickedVideoIdx":[],"events":[{"event":1,"offset":0},{"event":3,"offset":0,"arg":1},{"event":3,"offset":0,"arg":1.25},{"event":0,"offset":0.006696},{"event":1,"offset":15.706865}]}' \ --compressed

---

{ "name": "invalid_range", "id": "_l5kGLaa", "message": "body.duration must be lesser or equal than 60000 but got value 292484", "temporary": false, "timeout": false, "fault": false }

{ "success": false, "error": "Watch more content to get to the next level.", "data": null } { "success": false, "error": "the reward is not supposed to be visible to you, but here we are.", "data": null }

[juanpc2018]

there is also a lot of wallet balance requests.

[juanpc2018]

https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback {"name":"invalid_range","id":"K9-TXwOS","message":"body.duration must be lesser or equal than 60000 but got value 766570","temporary":false,"timeout":false,"fault":false}

(anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 u @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 l @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 le @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 u @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 l @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 re @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 videoIsPlaying @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 r.dispatcher.r.dispatcher @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 wr @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 trigger @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n.handleTechPause_ @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 r.dispatcher.r.dispatcher @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2

fetch("https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback", { "headers": { "accept": "application/json", "accept-language": "en-US", "content-type": "application/json", "sec-fetch-dest": "empty", "sec-fetch-mode": "cors", "sec-fetch-site": "cross-site" }, "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"rebuf_count\":1,\"rebuf_duration\":1325,\"url\":\"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a\",\"device\":\"dsk\",\"duration\":766570,\"protocol\":\"stb\",\"player\":\"\",\"user_id\":\"375630884\",\"position\":972000,\"rel_position\":100,\"bitrate\":2278609}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors", "credentials": "omit" });

fetch("https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback", { "headers": { "accept": "application/json", "accept-language": "en-US", "content-type": "application/json", "sec-fetch-dest": "empty", "sec-fetch-mode": "cors", "sec-fetch-site": "cross-site" }, "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"rebuf_count\":1,\"rebuf_duration\":1325,\"url\":\"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a\",\"device\":\"dsk\",\"duration\":766570,\"protocol\":\"stb\",\"player\":\"\",\"user_id\":\"375630884\",\"position\":972000,\"rel_position\":100,\"bitrate\":2278609}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors" });

curl 'https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback' \ -H 'authority: watchman.na-backend.odysee.com' \ -H 'accept: application/json' \ -H 'accept-language: en-US' \ -H 'content-type: application/json' \ -H 'sec-fetch-dest: empty' \ -H 'sec-fetch-mode: cors' \ -H 'sec-fetch-site: cross-site' \ -H 'user-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) LBRY/0.53.5-t109 Chrome/94.0.4606.81 Electron/15.4.0 Safari/537.36' \ --data-raw '{"rebuf_count":1,"rebuf_duration":1325,"url":"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a","device":"dsk","duration":766570,"protocol":"stb","player":"","user_id":"375630884","position":972000,"rel_position":100,"bitrate":2278609}' \ --compressed

[juanpc2018]

https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback

{"message":"rebufferung duration cannot be larger than duration"}

(anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 u @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 l @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 le @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 u @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 n @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 l @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 re @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 videoIsPlaying @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 sl @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Es @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 t.unstable_runWithPriority @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 Gi @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 xs @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 (anonymous) @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 F @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2 x.port1.onmessage @ file:///opt/LBRY/resources/app.asar/ui.js:2

fetch("https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback", { "headers": { "accept": "application/json", "accept-language": "en-US", "content-type": "application/json", "sec-fetch-dest": "empty", "sec-fetch-mode": "cors", "sec-fetch-site": "cross-site" }, "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"rebuf_count\":1,\"rebuf_duration\":1325,\"url\":\"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a\",\"device\":\"dsk\",\"duration\":7,\"protocol\":\"stb\",\"player\":\"\",\"user_id\":\"375630884\",\"position\":972000,\"rel_position\":100,\"bitrate\":2278609}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors", "credentials": "omit" });

fetch("https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback", { "headers": { "accept": "application/json", "accept-language": "en-US", "content-type": "application/json", "sec-fetch-dest": "empty", "sec-fetch-mode": "cors", "sec-fetch-site": "cross-site" }, "referrerPolicy": "strict-origin-when-cross-origin", "body": "{\"rebuf_count\":1,\"rebuf_duration\":1325,\"url\":\"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a\",\"device\":\"dsk\",\"duration\":7,\"protocol\":\"stb\",\"player\":\"\",\"user_id\":\"375630884\",\"position\":972000,\"rel_position\":100,\"bitrate\":2278609}", "method": "POST", "mode": "cors" });

curl 'https://watchman.na-backend.odysee.com/reports/playback' \ -H 'authority: watchman.na-backend.odysee.com' \ -H 'accept: application/json' \ -H 'accept-language: en-US' \ -H 'content-type: application/json' \ -H 'sec-fetch-dest: empty' \ -H 'sec-fetch-mode: cors' \ -H 'sec-fetch-site: cross-site' \ -H 'user-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) LBRY/0.53.5-t109 Chrome/94.0.4606.81 Electron/15.4.0 Safari/537.36' \ --data-raw '{"rebuf_count":1,"rebuf_duration":1325,"url":"@whatdamath#8/strangest-galaxies-in-the-universe,-ring#a","device":"dsk","duration":7,"protocol":"stb","player":"","user_id":"375630884","position":972000,"rel_position":100,"bitrate":2278609}' \ --compressed

[keikari]

Do comments work for you on older versions of the app?

[juanpc2018]

LBRYv0.53.3 was working ok, until v0.53.4 SDK change...

cannot test older, because do Not play video. https://github.com/lbryio/lbry-desktop/issues/7656

v0.53.5-t109 Play video, but Comments have issues,

Credit / coin counter stop working since SDK update in v0.53.4, unless i log-in to Odysee Web. LBRY does Not refreash / update coins.

Odysee comment issue its intermitent issue, "if video has too much comments, or too fast from others" Madiator is permanent issue since 0.53.4 Json error Network Status 502 https://comments.madiator.com/api/v2 since SDK update in v0.53.4

[keikari]

Don't think SDK affecting comments (also SDK update in v0.53.4 was very minor) Currently Odysee comments working fine here on 53.4.
What's the exact issue on Odysee comment server, do you mean that it errors if you send too many requests?

Madiator probably needs to fix something on his server.

What do you mean with "Credit / coin counter"? Do you mean that balance shows incorrectly? In that case, try to add this in your daemon_settings.yml and restart:

lbryum_servers:
  - spv16.lbry.com:50001

[juanpc2018]

Yes, Balance do Not increase, unless i log-in to Odysee Web, then it jumps.

[juanpc2018]

/usr/share/applications/lbry.desktop

[Desktop Entry]
Name=LBRY
Exec=/opt/LBRY/lbry %U
Terminal=false
Type=Application
Icon=lbry
StartupWMClass=LBRY
MimeType=x-scheme-handler/lbry;
Comment=A browser for the LBRY network, a digital marketplace controlled by its users.
Categories=AudioVideo;Video;

$ whereis lbry lbry: /usr/bin/lbry

/opt/LBRY/resources/static/daemon

dont know where is daemon_settings.yml

i dont have installed: https://github.com/lbryio/lbry-sdk

https://lbry.tech/resources/daemon-settings https://lbry.com/faq/lbry-directories

Linux

/opt/LBRY - LBRY application itself
~/.local/share/lbry/lbrynet - Daemon configuration and encrypted blob files
~/.local/share/lbry/lbryum - Wallet and blockchain headers
~/.lbrycrd - Location for [lbrycrdd](https://lbry.com/faq/standalone-wallet) full blockchain data (separate install)

*If you originally installed v0.14 and below, the lbrynet and lbryum directories will be ~/.lbrynet / ~/.lbryum

[juanpc2018]

Found it..

/home/user/.local/share/lbry/lbrynet/daemon_settings.yml

download_dir: /media/user/1TB/0-LBRY-dn
max_key_fee:
  amount: 1.0
  currency: USD
save_blobs: false
share_usage_data: true

lbryum_servers:
  - spv16.lbry.com:50001

Now i have to wait, Weekly Watch Reward

[keikari]

If you are talking about rewards, those were removed from the desktop app.

[juanpc2018]

what is the incentive to use the App?

This reminds me of Bitcoin Node Wallet, Original Satoshi Nakamoto Vision, was to include Free Transaction Fee, when CPU wallet was mining, but was removed after 0.10, because CPU was to slow vs. ASIC, but that was Not the point of Satoshi Nakamoto, was to avoid a 51% attack, motivating more people to have Full Node Wallets.

Anyway, i have: August 4th, 202210:09 AM | Payment | Weekly Watch Reward

Opening Odysee Web Updates LBRY Desktop balance.

You need to completly separate the Networks if you want to stop View Reward on LBRY. Fork The Chain / Networks.

removing code is fools game.

[keikari]

I think LBRY app is made so there is a easy/convenient way to use LBRY.

What do you mean with "Opening Odysee Web Updates LBRY Desktop balance"? Is balance wrong before you open Odysee, and how much is it off?

[juanpc2018]

Madiator probably needs to fix something on his server.

only he knows: @kodxana

i think the problem is LBRY-Desktop

[kodxana]

Madiator probably needs to fix something on his server.

only he can know: @kodxana

i think the problem is LBRY-Desktop

Yes my server is offline working on brining it back.

[juanpc2018]

I think LBRY app is made so there is a easy/convenient way to use LBRY.

What do you mean with "Opening Odysee Web Updates LBRY Desktop balance"? Is balance wrong before you open Odysee, and how much is it off?

LBRY-Desktop stop updating Balance... i watch 1 week, 2 week of videos, Balance in LBRY Desktop does Not change...

i open Odysee Web, Balance Updates on LBRY Desktop.

[keikari]

It sounds like you are talking about rewards. And those don't exist on the LBRY desktop app anymore, so sounds like expected/intended behavior.

[jessopb]

App has updates, should be fine now.