kirkhess
commented
11 months ago Libris has a solution - basically the PrimaryProvisionActivity could have a object property marc:publicationStatus, and then there are resources for each one of these:
- marc:ReprintReissueDateAndOriginalDate
- marc:NoDatesGivenBCDateInvolved
- marc:ContinuingResourceStatusUnknown
"r" is specifically a type of Provision Activity, marc:ReprintReissueAndOriginalPublication with two types of dates, reprintYear and originalYear.
:publication [ a marc:ReprintReissueAndOriginalPublication ;
:country <https://id.kb.se/country/xxk> ;
marc:reprintYear "2016" ;
marc:originalYear "2014" ;
marc:publicationStatus marc:ReprintReissueDateAndOriginalDate ]
We narrowed down the ways this byte is supported or not supported by BIBFRAME. There's two categories of this issue. One is something that is lossy where there's no support for the specific dtst code in BIBFRAME. The 2nd one is where the conversion specifications have an issue, those we'll document in the respective github repositories & I'll come back and add a link.
I tested these by converting sample records to BF using m2bf 2.3, converting the BF to marc using bibframe2marc 2.3. I also tested converting the cbd.rdf serialization from id to marc.
Codes
r - Reprint/reissue date and original date. Enter reprint/reissue date in Date 1 and date of original in Date 2.
Example:
r20191912changes tos2019||||Test records:
Summary: The way the specs and the conversions are written Date 2 is lost and the dtst is changed from r to s.
r is specified in marc2bibframe2 to ignore the Date2 which in our opinion is the case because there's no place to put this date, we request you fix this. There are approximately 800,000 LCCNs with this code.
b - No dates given; B.C. date involved. Use blanks in Dates if one or more of the dates are B.C.E. dates. Enter the appropriate code and B.C.E. date or dates in field 046.
Example:
bchanges to|||||||||In addition, there's no 046 support in BF: `
`
Test records:
Summary b is specified in marc2bibframe2 to be ignored as well as almost all of the 046 that is required with this code, we're requesting that you add support for b and all of the 046 field.
u - Continuing resource status unknown. No clear indication exists that publication of the continuing resource has ceased.
Example:
u197uuuuuis changed tom197uuuuuTest records:
Summary u has support in the specifications but it has the exact same specifications as m, which is first so it fires first in m2bf. I'm adding this here since it seems more ontological than conversion related (aka no place for the code).