search

lcnetdev / marc2bibframe2

Convert MARC records to BIBFRAME2 RDF
http://www.loc.gov/bibframe/
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
89 stars 35 forks source link

Field 388 #60

Closed kiegel closed 7 years ago

kiegel commented 7 years ago

We would like to see field 388 (Time period of creation) converted. It could be done easily based on the template you have established for field 386.

bflc:timePeriodOfCreation [ a bflc:TimePeriodOfCreation ; rdfs:label "388 Time Period of Creation subfield a" ; bflc:appliesTo [ a bflc:AppliesTo ; rdfs:label "388 subfield 3" ] ;
bf:source [ a bf:Source ; rdfs:label "388 subfield 2" ] ] .

kirkhess commented 7 years ago

It's marked as no attempt to code - if you send me an example record, I'll look into what we need to do to support this field.

kiegel commented 7 years ago

Here is a sample record in MARCXML. (not supported as an attachment)

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>

-

-

05226cam a2200829Ia 4500 99113001930001452 20170825065157.8 720531s1933 maua 000 d eng - 33025049 - 000486300 Uk - 006782536 Uk - 8889048 14021268 252556604 462463785 926757205 976858435 - (OCoLC)00321177 (OCoLC)8889048 (OCoLC)14021268 (OCoLC)252556604 (OCoLC)462463785 (OCoLC)926757205 (OCoLC)976858435 - (OCoLC)ocm00321177 - (EXLNZ-01ALLIANCE_NETWORK)9993318080001451 - DLC eng FIN SER OCL ZGM RMC WY@ DEBBG TTS UKMGB SGE GBVCP OCLCF OCLCQ OCLCO LMR BCO FYW CULIB OCLCQ OCL OCLCQ WAU OCLCO CNUTO OCLCA - MAIN - PR1263 .B7 - PR1263 B7 - 822.30822 - HI 1341 rvk - 7,25 ssgn - English drama, 1580-1642 / selected and edited by C.F. Tucker Brooke and Nathaniel Burton Paradise. - Boston : D.C. Heath & Co., ©1933. - viii, 1044 pages : illustrations ; 25 cm - text txt rdacontent - unmediated n rdamedia - volume nc rdacarrier - Sixteenth century Seventeenth century lcsh - Includes facsimile reproduction of the original or early title pages of twenty-nine of the thirty plays. The remaining play, The Spanish tragedy, is accompanied by a facsimile reproduction of a letter by Thomas Kyd preceded by a transcription on an unnumbered leaf. - The arraignment of Paris ; The old wives tale / George Peele -- Endymion / John Lyly -- Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay / Robert Greene -- The Spanish tragedy / Thomas Kyd -- Tamburlaine, part 1 ; Doctor Faustus ; The Jew of Malta ; Edward II / Christopher Marlowe -- The shoemakers' holiday / Thomas Dekker -- A woman killed with kindness / Thomas Heywood -- Bussy d'Ambois / George Chapman -- The malcontent / John Marston -- Eastward ho! / Chapman, Jonson, Marston -- Every man in his humour ; Volpone, or The fox ; Epicoene, or The silent woman ; The alchemist ; The gipsies metamorphosed / Ben Jonson -- The Duchess of Malfi / John Webster -- The knight of the burning pestle / Beaumont (and Fletcher?) -- Philaster ; The maid's tragedy / Beaumont and Fletcher -- The island princess / John Fletcher -- Beggars' Bush / Fletcher and Massinger -- A new way to pay old debts / Philip Massinger -- The changeling / Middleton and Rowley -- A game at chess / Thomas Middleton -- The broken heart / John Ford -- The Cardinal / James Shirley. - commitment to retain 20151204 pda OTUTLD - English drama Early modern and Elizabethan, 1500-1600. - English drama 17th century. - 1580 - 1642 fast - Drama. lcgft - Rowley, William, 1585?-1642?, author. - Brooke, Tucker, 1883-1946, editor. - Paradise, Nathaniel Burton, 1895-1942, editor. - Peele, George, 1556-1596. Arraignment of Paris. - Peele, George, 1556-1596. Old wives' tale. - Lyly, John, 1554?-1606. Endymion. - Greene, Robert, 1558-1592. Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay. - Kyd, Thomas, 1558-1594. Spanish tragedy. - Marlowe, Christopher, 1564-1593. Tamburlaine. Part 1. - Marlowe, Christopher, 1564-1593. Doctor Faustus. - Marlowe, Christopher, 1564-1593. Jew of Malta. - Marlowe, Christopher, 1564-1593. Edward the Second. - Dekker, Thomas, approximately 1572-1632. Shoemakers' holiday. - Heywood, Thomas, approximately 1574-1641. Woman killed with kindness. - Chapman, George, 1559?-1634. Bussy d'Ambois. - Marston, John, 1575?-1634. Malcontent. - Chapman, George, 1559?-1634. Eastward hoe. - Jonson, Ben, 1573?-1637. Every man in his humour. - Jonson, Ben, 1573?-1637. Volpone. - Jonson, Ben, 1573?-1637. Epicoene. - Jonson, Ben, 1573?-1637. Alchemist. - Jonson, Ben, 1573?-1637. Gypsies metamorphosed. - Webster, John, 1580?-1625? Duchess of Malfi. - Beaumont, Francis, 1584-1616. Knight of the burning pestle. - Beaumont, Francis, 1584-1616. Philaster. - Beaumont, Francis, 1584-1616. Maid's tragedy. - Fletcher, John, 1579-1625. Island princess. - Fletcher, John, 1579-1625. Beggars bush. - Massinger, Philip, 1583-1640. New way to pay old debts. - Middleton, Thomas, -1627. Changeling. - Middleton, Thomas, -1627. Game at chess. - Ford, John, 1586-approximately 1640. Broken heart. - Shirley, James, 1596-1666. Cardinal. - Online version: Brooke, Tucker, 1883-1946. English drama, 1580-1642. Boston, New York [etc.] D.C. Heath and Company [©1933] (OCoLC)609587462 - .b16658759 LOCAL - 92 OCACL
kirkhess commented 7 years ago

We've decided we're going to close this issue after evaluating the proposed solution and deciding it will not work. Also, apparently this field is not approved by NACO, which is one reason it is marked as no attempt to code in the specifications, and is probably why we have no LC examples. Thanks for the marcxml, we'll definitely revisit this field when we look at updating the ontology/specifications.

kiegel commented 7 years ago

Just noting that NACO is not relevant because the proposal is for the 388 in bib records. While LC may not have examples, it is being used by PCC libraries: OCLC #321177, #50028686, #3354935, #38539852, #969996605. Also, the proposed property is an addition to bflc, which is under LC's control, so it does not need to wait for an update to the bf ontology.

kirkhess commented 7 years ago

I'll pass that on, thanks for the OCLC numbers. The field is marked as "no attempt to code" in the specs, I don't doubt it's used or useful but we can't convert it until we have a spec. If it looks like they'll actually attempt to model this in the ontology and write a spec we'll reopen this issue.

Thanks!

-Kirk

On Wed, Nov 8, 2017 at 12:57 PM, Joe Kiegel notifications@github.com wrote:

Just noting that NACO is not relevant because the proposal is for the 388 in bib records. While LC may not have examples, it is being used by PCC libraries: OCLC #321177, #50028686, #3354935, #38539852, #969996605. Also, the proposed property is an addition to bflc, which is under LC's control, so it does not need to wait for an update to the bf ontology.

— You are receiving this because you modified the open/close state. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/lcnetdev/marc2bibframe2/issues/60#issuecomment-342901079, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABWqki2xbqkul4mTu3CqnEhj6PCn9Opnks5s0et6gaJpZM4QIJo4 .